Tuesdays 8:00 PM on ABC Family
Pretty-little-liars
10980 posts
Floralovesgurlplz

 

Alright so I notice that people make little debates and perspective on who can't possibly be A and who could be, which leads to heated arguments (not just here, fanforum..etc) So I'm basically gonna break this down (hopefully this wont be too long to read)

 

 

Also I am aware there may possibly be more than one A.If this post gets fucked up by text fail I will re post it sorry

 

 

Here are the main suspects fans speculate:

 

 

Mona: Mona is often assumed to be A quite a lot since book mona is A. But, as I repeat, the books =/= the show. The Pilot showed her as a geek who was trying to be friends with Aria and Ali. That is the only motive we can pick  up to believe Mona is A, but she has been occupied or glued to Hanna when A has messed with the girls. Example: A giving Emily a massage while Mona and Hanna were chasing down ponies. ponies <3

 

Ezra: Aria has been not nearly as tortured by A as the girls, which is why I want to punch her sometimes for saying A ruins her life yeah anyway so I've seen people say often that they think this is because Ezra is A. It's a pretty good theory. But Ezra freaked out when A sent him a text last season and kicked Aria out believing she was telling people about the relationship.

 

 

Noel: Like Jenna and Toby, the girls immediately jumped on the we-now-know-who-A-is wagon, which obviously meant he wasn't A since this show wouldn't be that predictable. The most suspicious thing with Noel is that he was re-enrolled right after Ian went missing from the church. He also smirked at Aria after giving her the dvd which had the Ali-hate tribute. Overall Noel seems to obviously be a character thrown in to keep us guessing.

 

 

Jenna: At the moment it seems that Jenna totally knows A exists and what A may be doing to the girls. For me, I believe that she is either working with A or has taken influence off A and messed with the girls the same way the original A does. Jenna is the first character that put fear in the girls in the Pilot, once again this is too obvious of a character. Season 2 has proved her to be more of a villain, and hinting that she possibly took part in killing Ali. And lastly, Jenna and Garret were both in the police station while A was greeted by the waitress who said "hey there pretty eyes"

 

 

Garret: After the scheme he and Jenna did with the girls, it looked 100 percent that either of them were A, that was until A was in the restaurant meeting Sullivan. This means that either there were more than 2 A's, or that Jenna and Garret are working with A. Garret's relationship with Jenna is random and has yet to be explained how they even got together or why they are together, so Garret is a hard character to interpret since his motives make no sense. He seems to be simply working for Jenna.

 

 

Lucas: Lucas has been bullied by Alison, and it's caused him to also be scared of the girls because they were her "minions" We have not seen enough of Lucas/Ali to understand his extreme hate for her, but it's obviously serious if he had to shit all over the memorial bench. For me personally, his serious expression in 2x11 at Sullivan's speech made it look quite believable that he's been involved. Lucas however is too much of a good friend to Hanna, so it seems unlikely that he may be A unless he is doing it by blackmail or force.

 

 

Ben: Ben is believed to be A because he can't get over the fact that Emily dumped him for a girl. Naw im trollin moving on

 

 

Caleb: Caleb's background just screams a lot of obvious. The fact that he has gotten to be somewhat of a slightly-main male character in season 2 makes fans believe that it's leading up to something. Connect the fact that he hacks phones for a living to the girls being stalked by a blocked number, it is possible he set the blocked number up for A without knowing who A is, though fans has stated many times that Caleb came to Rosewood way after A messed with the girls. I don't think this should cross Caleb out for suspicion. He told Hanna about the stuff he did with the dmv in Alington, and he awkwardly told her that he has seen a dead body before (as she said she saw Ian's body).

 

 

A recent interview last week, Ashley (Hanna) stated that if/when Hanna tells Caleb about A, she hopes it does not cause him to leave again.

 

 

Jason: lol give me a break. Anyway like Jenna, Toby and Noel, the girls (well spencer) has jumped on him immediately. It is pretty clear that Jason has secrets and is hiding things, though for now he appears to just be a Toby 2.0 since he is creeping neighbors out, yet has gotten one of the girls to sympathize and understand him, and lastly he appears to be being blackmailed. This all just screams Toby the II. I'll be waiting for Spencer to give him his mail on his porch and say she's gonna tutor japanese with him.

 

 

Ian: IIRC, Ian sort of told spencer at the church that it was him who made the "Watch your back, I didn't -A" picture on her laptop. So it appears that Ian either was an A or was being influenced on A to get spencer to shut up. Once again I found Ian too obvious, but he defenitely was an antagonist.

 

 

Melissa: Melissa has barely mentioned Ali but whenever she does she appears to be so blunt about it. "Maybe that's how she got herself killed" Ian to Spencer: "I'm doing this (killing spencer) because I love her" stupid since I doubt Melissa would want Spencer dead, but Melissa clearly seems to have secrets. And of course we have a big cliff hanger from her in 2x05 after the funeral "I have something to tell you that I havent had the courage to say for awhile" This all seems more likely that Melissa took part in killing Ali moreso than being A.

 

 

Maya: Hanna noticed Maya's boots in the mid-finale, and A has bought a pair of boots recently near the end of an episode. That was the only scene we saw of Maya in the finale. It is odd that Maya has returned out of nowhere, even if Emily is the one who called her. There has to be a reason for her coming back, either that or she's just back to be a love interest to make me snore again. Maya was at the homecoming dance while getting pissed that sexy Toby was Emily's date, and A was painting the Rosewood population sign near the end of this ep. So Maya may not be A.

 

Kate's Horse: That stupid horse ditched hanna and mona because it had to run and go give Em a massage.

 

Ali: Ali has spoken to Hanna and Em through dream sequences, though both of the dreams felt so real. Emily touched her lips from thek iss after talking to Ali in the finale, and Hanna's water had a lipstick stain on it, which was exactly the color of Ali's lips, and Hanna had no makeup on. It would be pretty bold of Ali (if she is alive) to have visited Hanna and Emily, but the main question is that if Ali is A, what sense would that make? Other than spencer, she does not appear to have anything against the girls to want to torture them the way A does. And lastly, Ali's "ghost" having a bitch rant with Hanna in Sullivan's office leading to "nosey bitches die" written on the office wall.

 

ANYWAY if there is anything you guys want to add feel free in case you believe I left some characters out. Yeah this is long as hell but I wanted to do it. Thanks~

 

Posted at
10980 posts
Floralovesgurlplz

And of course, I forget to add an obvious.

Mike: not much needs to be explained, he's gotten his period and started going emo for season two, was engaged in a conversation with someone online before going chuck norris on his mom, and has been breaking into homes (something A is known to do) out of nowhere. Most likely it appears he is either A or working with A. Overall, another character that appears to be too obvious.

/done

Posted at

wow that must have taken you ages! 

dont worry iv done the same thing :') 

ashley has confirmed we have seen A on screen multiple times and that doesnt narrow it down atall -.-

im still leaning toward maya or lucas - but idk why. iv got a feeling the halloween episode is going to change alot of our theory's on lucas as its been confirmed he a massive part of the halloween episode.

Posted at

Maya and Lucas are just so obvious! Especially with Maya's look when Hanna glanced at her boots and the upcoming Halloween episode with a very featured Lucas.

I think we have to think very screwed up thoughts like e.g. my Byron theory (not saying that he's A or Ali's killer, it was just a thought). It has to be someone in the background yet featured a lot.

 

 

Posted at

omg byron.. he scares the crap outta me!

Posted at

He is rather scary, but I've always like Chad Lowe (and his brother!)

 

But it makes sense for Byron to kill Ali. In case some haven't read my theory, here it is again. Byron returned to Rosewood with his family after a year in Iceland and Ali also returned a year after she allegedly disappeared. Ali was with Aria when Byron's affair was discovered and when she returned, she found out that Byron had renewed his affair with his former student and becuase Byron didn't wnat to ruin his marriage, he killed Ali. (This could also work if he killed her and buried her when she first disappeared). Besides that, Mike is so afraid that Ella will leave his father again which indicates that Mike knows that Byron has an affair yet again.

 

 

Posted at

Ben: Ben is believed to be A because he can't get over the fact that Emily dumped him for a girl. Naw im trollin moving on

Kate's Horse: That stupid horse ditched hanna and mona because it had to run and go give Em a massage.

LOL. Just when I'm seriously reading something, you put this part that made me LOL.   My main suspects for A: 1. Lucas -- he fits the description of a villain. Starts out innocent, cute, quirky, then problem arises when he destroyed the Alison's bench something. Then he kinda zoned out of the show then appears again at Sullivan's speech with a weird expression then play the important role in Halloween eps.   2. Melissa -- She has a motive for murdering Alison. And she's just so suspicious all this time. But then again she doesn't have anything against the girls.   3. Ezra. Those pretty eyes reference. Aria told Ezra in a text that he had pretty eyes. So is it really that easy as ABC?    
Posted at
Yah
Guest
Am I the only one here who doesn't think Garret and Jenna? ABC family makes things obvious just to throw us off track again. Pretty eyes, not Jenna, too dark glasses!! Jason, blue eyes, so cute, having a reason, a reward for all whatever Garrett and Jenna were talking about. Why did he cover up the windows? So he could search the place for Ali's secrets. I think Ali made a butt-load of cash hid it in the house and that's why Jason wants it. She hid stuff all in the house, Jason's just trying to find it, finding more about the girls. He also know Doctor Sullivan because he'd need a therapist after his sister died! If this doesn't clear things up, I don't know what will.
Posted at
10980 posts
Floralovesgurlplz

@ Aquariuz I would love for it to be Ezra because that's really someone we wouldn't expect, and it would really explain why Aria isn't as abused compared to the 3. But like I said in my post he freaked out when A texted him which made him think Aria was telling people about them sooo i dunno unless he just to text himself for luls.

@Yah I'm pretty sure most viewers don't think A is Jenna and Garret or that both of them are the killers. And as for Jason I really doubt he's A, but if he knows A or has worked with him/her yeah probably

Posted at
claire
Guest

i really dont think it's jenna or garett. i mean, they seem like the most obvious choices. i def. do think they have to do with ali's murder and know about A, but it would be pretty boring if they turned out to be A. I do hope it's ezra though! I think that would make a wonderful story :)

Posted at

Post a Reply

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register.

Guest posting is disabled in this forum. If you want to post, please Sign In or Register.

Want more Pretty Little Liars?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

Pretty Little Liars Quotes

Ok, Mona, we get it! You can freaking sing!

Hanna

You think the truth is this big shiny disco ball of purity then go ahead and try it. See what it gets you. Telling the truth to the wrong person at the wrong time is how I ended up where I did. Take it from me you're always better off with a really good lie.

Alison
x Close Ad