What if the first Petrova doppelganger is an original and a sister of Klaus and Elijah???
Everyone (or nearly everyone) knows that since 2x08 and 2x09 I've been shipping Katherine and Elijah together. Even though some people doubted me, said it was ridiculous and most people are now shipping them since 2x19.
Anyway, lately I've been having serious doubts about them actually having something romantic between them. What if the reason Elijah wanted to save Katherine and also said that she reminded him of someone, is because she reminds him of his sister??? What if she was their only sister out of all the brothers and that because of Klaus being a werewolf and a vampire, the witches put the doppelganger curse on her, cause they thought that Klaus wouldn't want to sacrifice his own sister. What if the witches hid her, faked her death, but she's still alive??? Maybe that's why Elijah wanted to save Katherine, cause she reminded him of his little sister, that he adored and he hoped that he could replace her with Katherine. Maybe that's also why he cares about Elena too...
This is just a theory...I'm still between this theory and shipping KathJah....haha
Even if we call her the first Petrova doppelganger...doesn't mean she's a Petrova...
But Elijah said to Klaus in the flashback that they loved once... and I don't think that he meant "brother or sister love", you know what I mean? And I ship KathJah!!! :)
I know, but it could mean that too I guess...
I don't know...it was just one crazy theory that came to me...haha
But I do think that it could be possible...and that we may be reading into them wrong...haha
That bit disturbing!!!! C'mon he would of mentions to everyone that his sister long time ago. but it can't be. she must of remind Elijah the women he love before. they wouldnt to kill if she was their sister. Katherine like both brothers and Klaus wanted use her to sacrifice herself and Elijah didn't have the gut to do that, which is why he broke Klaus trust. I'm seeing Elijah's point of view and i'm on Elijah side. You got to think the logical story behind this.
So latelly I've been seriously thinking about this too and came to this theory.
When Klaus and Elijah were still humans they fell in love with the same girl.Charlotte Petrova or what her name really is.The girl chose Klaus instead of Elijah.They became vampires and the girl was scared of him and ran away.The word was out that Klaus isnt only a vampire but a hybrid and the witches wanted to diminuate his forces by placing a curse on him.In order to seal the curse they needed blood that would make Klaus weak, and the curse strong."Love is a vampire's greatest weakness".Then the witches proposed to the original Petrova a deal.To make this sacrifice in order to make Klaus less stronger and they will create doppelgangers of her that will live their lifes in peace,because she couldnt.But that was the catch...the blood of the doppelgangers has the power to break the curse.
I thought maybe the Petrova original was their mom,sister...but no,she was human.And the curse was placed after they turned,all of them including his siblings and parents.But good theory @TeamDamon4ever
She can be long distance realatives to Klaus and Elijah (i.e 2nd, 3rd cousins)????? Old days people use to do that back in history.
Elijah said they used to care. I am pretty sure he refers to once they were humans and their humanity, it would make more sense. Elijah never broked Klaus' trust? It wasen't Elijah who sent away Katherine. He said that Katherine took matters into her own hands. Katherine running weren't Elijah's doing. The "Charlotte Petrova" thing was a joke, and the name Charlotte dosen't make sense anyway. I don't think the witches maked the curse to make Klaus kill someone he might or might not have loved. How is love a vampires greatest weakness when they can turn off their emotions? I would say vervain or wood is a greater weakness. With @Luana's theory, i have to assume the original Petrova cared for people even as a vampire. If she did care, how could she make a deal, where her family have to be killed in order to break it?
And it would seem as Klaus dosen't care abot anyone. He hate Elijah, and he dosen't care about anyone but himself.
It seems to much of a stretch, and if it was true, they would include it in the story. And for Nina Dobreva to be 3 characters would be to crowded, and it wouldn't be good.
I guessed maybe the girl was human and was scared of Klaus when she saw him as a vamp and thats why she agreed with the witches...but neah...u're right @Halde it would be too much of a stretch...and 3 characters for Nina..different acting and stuff it would be overwhelming...ehh bad theory of mine haha
I am not sure the original doppelganger is related to the original family. To become a warewolf you have to kill a person and to become a vampire you have to drink their blood. I am thinking maybe Klaus killed the original Petrova by drinking her blood or something which is what made him a warewolf and a vampire at the same time, but I'm not sure how that fits in with the timeline because the family didn't discover Klaus was a warewolf until after they were turned into vampires. So the curse had to be placed on him after he was already a vampire and a warewolf.