The Fae Council decides that a Stag Hunt will determine the new Ash on Lost Girl. "I Fought the Fae (And the Fae Won)" is the 2nd episode of the show's 2nd season.
Added:

Lost Girl Season 2 Episode 2 Quotes

You kinda sprung some big stuff on me. Trading in your feelings to save my live -- that's one messed-up love letter.

Bo

How many couples get to fall in love twice?

Bo