Did Hollie deserve to be eliminated on this week's American Idol?
hollie should have stayed and joshua should have gone home
Hollie should have gone home weeks ago! I cannot believe Elise & Skylar were voted off before her. I can't believe she even made it to the top 10.
Holly should have went a long time ago. she has a good voice, just does not touch the fans. the three that are left are amazing singers. ALL 3 deserve to win. Each has incredible talent and understanding of music and how to feel what they are singing. This will be a tough race to the end. Wish Josh, Jessica and Phil best of luck. Would buy all of their albums.
Jessica has more talent than anyone on this show. Tonight, I didn't really care if it was Hollie or Phillip that went home because neither can come close to Jessica or Joshua.
This show is AMERICAN Idol. America already voted Jessica off of the show. She shouldn't still be there. I think the "save" is a joke. Hollie was the worst this week, she deserved to go home. Yes she is amazing singer but there can only be 1 winner, and this week it just wasn't Hollie.
Ahbooboo, Carmie and Gazu!!! too bad for the three of you Jessica is still in the top 3!!!! You don't know how to recognize a real talent!!! Boooooooo!!!!!
Another great singer is gone those of you that are still pulling for Phillip give your head a shake . Hollie you out sing this wana be star.
Those of you who say Phillip should have gone awhile ago....Phillip is the only true artist on the show. The way he hears and makes music is a gift. It is something none of the other contestants possess. Plus he has such a distinct voice. He is the only reason why I watch the show.
i predict this will be neck and neck between jessica and joshua.... both have shown tremendous talent and versatility all throughout the competition and i'd hate to see a loser between the two but am rooting for J------!!
It was obivious last night who the judges want to win it. It is time to run these so called judges off the show. I am sick of them. I do not care who wins it. None of the final five can compare to last years final 2.
© 2015 TV Fanatic
TV Fanatic Plus
Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive personalized television news for