Which of the new American Idol judges is the best addition to the panel?

Like Us On Facebook

Want more ?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Art-and-murder

Who do you want to see Daniel in a relationship with?

Who do you want to see Daniel in a relationship with?
Ali-moved-in

Did Alison know about Bethany?

How much did Alison really know about Bethany Young?
Chasing-life-with-strippers

Will Leo decide to fight and have surgery?

Will Leo decide to fight and have surgery?

Related Post:
Created by:
Created at:
Avatar

Well I do agree with alot ofthe ccomments above mine. I felt that Mikki is just something to watch because of how she look from show to show, its crazy as hell and funny, and I do love Mariah but it always seems like she is taking shots at Nikki. I feel like ya'll are suppost to be grown ass women so act like it cuz this a family show. Randy the last one standing but adds nothing to the show anymore, and all he has ever said was (YO! she/he is in it to win it. damn Randy change up some time cuz your boring now. And then there is Keith, all I have to say is he's great and when he speaks, he's always on point. And he is eye candy not like Nikki....lol. And watched this show from the start and I never miss it.

Avatar

Seriously, did Nikki have to pay the network to be on the show? Keith and Mariah are a class act, and poor Randy needs to go to Toastmasters and learn some new vocabulary. Save some money, tape his comments once, and put up a cardboard Randy in his chair from then on. Poor guy, what does he do for living without you? You dress the singers, sign that boy up.

Avatar

I think Nikki is a crackup and don't take much of what she has to say too seriously. Don't think anyone else does either.

Avatar

I do not like Nikki. I think she is going to poison the show to where people will quit watching it. She is discusting. I do not like the show this year mainly because of her. They talk entirely too much about nothing.They need to shorten there comments. Make it short and sweet and to the point. I love Keith. Keith Urban is the only new judge that I would leave on there.He does a good job. The show has certainly went down hill by a long shot. It is going to find itself off the air if they dont make some changes. I have watched it every season from the get go and this season is by far the worse they have had and it is because of the judges. The only reason I am watching is because I have not missed a season, other than that I would not have watched it. Terrible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ryan Seacrest is the best host in the world. He does an awesome job. They better keep him for sure. He makes the show.!!!

Avatar

After reading all those comments I totally agree, Nikki Minaj is an embarrasment to the female race. She is so jealous of Mariah! Fox must have got her cheap. Please do not bring her back next season if there is a next season! I would like to see judges like; Aretha Franklin, Gladys Knight, Patti LaBelle, Cheryl Crow. And for the guys, I like Smoky Robinson, Jeffery Osborne, Michael Brullee. Keith Urban is really trying to hang in there, I kind of feel sorry for him sitting next to Nikki. And Randy, he's no help at all he shoul have been gone along time ago. It was a great show when Simon Cowell was on. American Idol seems to have lost its edge.

Avatar

Nikki Minaj is not qualified to be a judge. She is insulting and dominating, and I hate that Randy sits back and lets it happen. She will cause someone weak to commit suicide. Insults and ignorant words are not what this show is about. REALLY MISS WATCHING REAL JUDGING. REALLY MISS SIMON COWELL. THIS IS NOT A FREAK SHOW ABOUT NIKKI MINAJ WANTING TO MARRY GIRLS AND CALLING PEOPLE HER MARSHMALLOW! PLEASE GET RID OF HER. I QUIT WATCHING.

Avatar

get rid of that useless, childish nikki. never had much of an opinion of miriah before, but at least she has class and dignity. nikki is below standard.

Avatar

Oh my goodness, where in heavens name did you come up with that person, Nicki Minaj. She is pathetic and is clearly dragging the show down down down. Send her back from wherever she came from with a one way ticket!

Avatar

Get rid of Nicki Minaj. She is poisoning the show. The Voice has two new judges and they are an asset to the show. However Minaj is a very mean, disrespectful person. She stays I will channel check and be done with
American Idol. Keith and Mariah are thumbs up, but Nicki is clearly thumbs down.

Avatar

Nikki is actually disgusting looking. Mariah allllllllllllll the way :)