Max and Caroline try to make a cake for a bride (played by guest star Lindsay Lohan) who changes her mind repeatedly and nearly sends Max over the edge. When the cake is finally done, the girls then have the challenge of getting it to the service, in a subway no less, and then find that the bride has changed her mind about the entire wedding.

With their precious paycheck on the line, Max dons a wedding dress to try and fool the wedding planner. In the end, the cake is ruined, the bride is married but questioning her sexuality, and Max admits that she is still hurting over her breakup with Deke.