Are you a TV Fanatic?
Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive personalized television news for free!
WOW. Did anyone see that coming? We always knew Michael Lynche had personality and a solid voice... but his rendition of "This Woman's Work" was one of the most memorable in American Idol history. Don't believe us?
Just ask Kara DioGuardi. If she ever stops crying from it, that is.
Sadly, aside from Big Mike, the rest of the guys were mediocre at best. Here's a rundown of our favorite five:
Who did you like the best?