Jenna tries to contain her secret hooks up with Colin away from Matty, but her secret is eventually out to Tamara who begins having a hard time keeping it under wraps until Jenna can find the right moment. As Jenna puts off telling Matty she ends up finding herself more and more with Colin.

Meanwhile, Lacey is working on throwing Jenna a surprise party, and, after Lacey tricks Jenna into thinking she and Kevin are going to Sea World, Jenna brings Colin home and begins to make out with him in front of the watchful eyes of the surprise party.