Duets take center stage on this episode of Glee as Finn assigns Ryder and Jake and Marley and Kitty the task of working together to sing duets. Ryder and Jake share their biggest fears with one another to form a friendship while Kitty pretends to be friends with Marley in an attempt to lure her away from both boys.

The Warblers steal the New Directions' Nationals trophy and promise to return it if Blaine leaves McKinley to rejoin them before Sectionals. He considers leaving McKinley since everything there reminds him of Kurt but chooses to stay after talking to Sam.