Thanksgiving comes to Glee this week. Rachel and Kurt make plans to stay in New York. Brody cooks dinner for the three of them, but Kurt invites Isabelle who invites a few friends. Isabelle encourages Kurt to accept Blaine's apology so that he can move on.

In Ohio, the graduates have all returned home for Thanksgiving and to help prep the New Directions for sectionals. Santana and Quinn argue when Santana discovers that Kitty has been encouraging Marley's bulimia. Jake helps Ryder prepare his dance for sectionals, but Ryder backs out of the lead at the last minute because he believes Jake to be the better dancer. Marley collapses during the New Directions performance.