On New Girl Season 5 Episode 8, Reagan gets frustrated with Nick and Winston when they aren't able to make a decision about where to go for brunch. She asks the both of them if they have ever made a decision in their lives, but the guys try to convince Reagan they have. Reagan comes up with a plan, if Winston and Nick can decide who gets to have sex with her she will go along with it. The guys are shocked by this turn of events and go into the bedroom to discuss who will sleep with Reagan. Reagan assures Schmidt and Cece she isn't actually going to go along with it, but she just wants the guys to figure out how to make their own decisions.

Winston and Nick fight over who should sleep with Reagan, but Winston wins the argument when it's revealed Nick French kissed a girl Winston liked back in the fifth grade. They tell Reagan who scares Winston by telling him he needs to stretch and do other odd things to prepare for the sex. Winston has a heart to heart with his partner Ali and she assures him he has kind eyes and shouldn't be insecure. Winston starts talking to Reagan and Nick about Ali and they both realize Winston has feelings for Ali. Winston goes to invite Ali out for drinks, but he's disappointed when he finds out Ali is dating someone else. 

Meanwhile, Schmidt and Cece go looking for the perfect wedding venue. Unfortunately they are on a budget and aren't able to go with the fancy venue Schmidt has always had his eye on. Schmidt tells Cece he is fine with not getting the venue because he is marrying her which makes everything better. The two of them decide to go ahead and book a soon to be vacant warehouse. 

Want to relieve Nick and Winston's bickering match? Go watch New Girl online now via TV Fanatic.