Leslie tries to find as many eligible bachelors as she can for Ann during Pawnee’s Valentine’s Day Dance. Sadly, none of them really spark anything with her. While talking and laughing to Tom, April realizes that Ann should give Tom and chance and go out for drinks.

Meanwhile, Ben, Ron, and Andy work together to solve Leslie’s incredibly intricate love scavenger hunt. Ben puts all of the pieces together and meets Leslie at Lil’ Sebastian’s grave.

The two decide to blow off their romantic date in attempt to go rub Chris and Ann’s face in their decision to restart their romance. Much to their shock, Ann is on a date with Tom.