Jim, Toby, and Gabe make up the search committee that is out to find the new manager for Dunder Mifflin Scranton. Many outsiders have come in to interview, while many of those in the office also are attempting to win the position.
Meanwhile, Creed continues his post as interim manager with empty meetings, empty acronyms, and fake phone calls to Pam. Also, Phyllis and Erin think that they might be mother and daughter so they get it tested. It turns out that it isn't the case, but Phyllis doesn't have the heart to tell Erin.