In the cold opening, the Dunder Mifflin crew watch the Scranton Strangler finally get caught by the police on the news. They then realize that he's being chased right by their building and Michael is the only one that sees the chase through the window.
Erin invites everyone from the office to her Glee viewing party. Michael gets upset when he finds out that some of the employees think of Gabe as the boss of the office. After acting like a complete jerk for most of the night, Michael finally cuts the cable from the house and ruins the party.
Cece is sleeping during the day and staying up all night, but Dwight steps in and gets her to fall asleep in his arms. He tries to leave to go rendezvous with Angela, but Pam convinces him to stay.
Andy is still really upset that Erin likes Gabe and gets drunk off of Seahorse powder. His night ends after getting sick on Gabe's bed.
Once he realizes that Erin wants Michael to like Gabe because she thinks of him as a father, he makes nice with Gabe.