American Idol Shocker, Take II: Carly Smithson Eliminated!

at . Comments

It wasn't as shocking as the elimination of Michael Johns, but we didn't imagine anyone except Brooke White would get ousted from American Idol this week.

Instead, Carly Smithson was shown the door.

We're flabbergasted. It's nice viewers felt bad for Brooke after she forgot the lyrics Tuesday night and all, but come on - it was her time to go. Smithson's performance of "Jesus Christ Superstar" was inspired in our view.

Carly Smithson

It was the end of the line for Carly Smithson tonight. Do you think she deserved to go?

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.