Skip to Content

Chicago Fire’s Latest Casting Move Feels Like a Slap in the Face

Over the last few years, Chicago Fire has had a higher turnover than a fast food joint.

It seems like every season, a fan-favorite character is departing the show and being replaced faster than they can leave.

There has been a lot of spinning and positive twisting from creatives and suits associated with the show as they focus on the positive side of these departures and explain the rationale behind them.

(Peter Gordon/NBC)

But we would be kidding ourselves if we said that it’s all flowers and sunshine for a firehouse that preaches family values and experiences departures every few months.

Chicago Fire is Switching Too Many Things Up

Daniel Kyri and Jake Lockett will be leaving Chicago Fire in Season 14, and a recent casting announcement by Variety reveals a replacement has been lined up.

On Call and 13 Reasons Why star Brandon Larracuente has been cast in an undisclosed role, but it is expected to be significant.

This seems like an attempt to replace Carver and Ritter, but the question becomes: why bother?

Daniel Kyri on Chicago Fire cast.
(Parrish Lewis/NBC)

The reason behind both actors’ departure was that Chicago Fire wanted to cut production costs. However, isn’t it counterproductive to try to cut costs, only to add another series regular?

Wouldn’t it be easier to keep the ones you already have instead of crafting an entirely new character and trying to recreate the same storylines over and over again?

Having seen numerous people come to Firehouse 51 and leave, I can almost predict what this new character’s arc will be, at least in Season 14.

A lot of time will be spent trying to sell them the idea of how close-knit 51 is, and they can let their guard down there.

Carver at a fire scene
(George Burns Jr/NBC)

We already did that with Carver, and it was one of the best iterations of the storyline.

Carver has connected with many fans and has turned out to be one of the best people in the firehouse.

It would be beneficial for the narrative to keep him, instead of bringing in another generic firefighter.

The Writers Need to Do Better

Don’t get me started on Darren Ritter, who the writers have criminally underutilized.

Despite being a series regular, it has always felt like they have never known what to do with him.

Daniel Kyri as Darren Ritter on Chicago Fire.
(Peter Gordon/NBC)

I recall an interview opportunity with Kyri that came up, but I had to pass on it because there was nothing for us to discuss regarding the character.

I played out the interview in my head, and could see both of us becoming uncomfortable as we discussed all the ways the show had let him down over the years, while sharing entries on our wishlist that would never come true.

Losing Ritter would be an even bigger loss for Chicago Fire which does not have decent queer representation, let alone from an actual queer person of color.

This is not meant to be a criticism of Larracuente, who did a great job on On Call, and I’m sure he’ll excel in the role.

Carver and a crying man at a fire scene
(George Burns Jr/NBC)

However, it feels like adding insult to injury after robbing viewers of good characters, however abused and misused some have been, only to replace them with someone else.

It’ll take a while before viewers connect with the new character, if we ever do. The worst part is that it is unnecessary to put us through this.

Open up in the comments section. Are you excited about this new character? Is Chicago Fire hurting itself with these departures?

Let’s talk about it.

It’s like screaming into a five-alarm blaze sometimes — but if you’re feeling the flames too, yell with me.

Drop a comment, share with your fellow Firehouse 51 fans, and send some good vibes our way. Every bit helps keep this engine running. Thanks for riding it out with me. 🔥

Watch Chicago Fire Online

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.

Elliot

Monday 30th of June 2025

The Natalie storyline this season was a complete waste of time. Dont get the point of it at all. They could have used that time screentime to give Ritter a storyline.

Arlene

Sunday 29th of June 2025

The only excuse they have is cops & firefighters in real life die all the time. Other than that it's criminal. Never did get attached to Carver but the kid Darren Ritter plays is loveable and just a good - hearted person, that he is leaving is upsetting. As for third youngg woman playing a cop on Chicago Fire to leave, or on FBI, likewise, leaving. something about that makes me feel queasy.

dd

Saturday 28th of June 2025

3rd gay parade character in the row on the show... but dude whines it has lack of representation for the gay parade. lmao

Joan Garcia

Friday 27th of June 2025

As a long-time Chicago Fire fan from the beginning, I'm done. It's their show, but if writers are tying to lose viewers, they've succeeded with me. They keep firing popular characters, which is too frustrating.

Jasmine Blu

Friday 27th of June 2025

Not only firing the popular characters but the actual characters with the most potential to carry plots. When I think back to last season, the only one who had a halfway decent, consistent arc that felt like it was going somewhere WAS Carver. Like, what are they even going to focus on next season? Beyond Stellaride family stuff? This new person that they'll likely axe by the end of the season? It's ridiculous. They sideline and waste most of the characters they do have, and then cut people.

Lonetta veselsky

Friday 27th of June 2025

I hate that you're losing these characters on chicago fire. Why hire a new character when you have two great characters already. If. It's about money then let go one only and keep one. To me that makes more sense

Jasmine Blu

Friday 27th of June 2025

Maybe they're using only a portion of both of their salaries to pay for a season-long series regular, and then they'll cut him to come end of season and do it all again.

Most Commented

TV Fanatic

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!