Skip to Content

Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 Review: Sink Or Swim

Critic's Rating: 4.8 / 5.0
4.8

Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 wasted no time before throwing the hospital into chaos.

A mass casualty event happened at the worst possible time, but it was a great way to introduce the medical drama’s new era.

The medical cases were almost secondary to the character conflicts, and that’s how it has always been for Med. Hopefully, the rest of the season will be as strong as this opening.

Horizontal photo of Lenox overseeing patient care during a mass casualty event on Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr.)

Goodbye, Dr. Marcel… Hello, Dr. Frost

Med’s Newest Resident Helps Ease The Pain Of Losing Marcel

When Chicago Med announced Dominic Rains’s departure as Crockett Marcel, I didn’t think anything would ease the pain of losing my favorite character.

Marcel’s absence was explained in a blink-and-you-miss-it moment when Ripley mentioned a farewell party before Marcel went to Boston.

It’s irritating that Dick Wolf shows keep doing this (yes, FBI franchise, I’m looking at you!). People’s disappearances are all explained after the fact instead of preparing for the loss ahead of time.

This one worked better than most, however. Marcel’s last scenes made it so questionable that he would return to Med for Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 that it wasn’t surprising that he didn’t.

At least it sounds like he left on good terms rather than remaining as depressed as he was during the season 9 finale.

New doctor John Frost accompanying a teenage Black girl in a wheelchair on Chicago Med S10 E1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr.)

Newbie John Frost’s introduction helped heal my heart from Marcel’s loss. When I first saw him, I thought he looked like Marcel and his personality was similar to Marcel’s when he first arrived.

Frost: You’re an angel.

Maggie: And you’re annoying.

Frost: I hope it becomes more endearing as you get to know me.

Frost’s introduction during Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 made him seem like a younger, still-green version of Marcel. He had the same perfect blend of cockiness and passion for patient care but still has a lot to learn.

One of the first lessons for him will likely to be to stay on Maggie’s good side. Their banter was cute, but if he crossed the line to more annoying instead of less, she wouldn’t hesitate to let him have it.

He won over by the end of the hour, though, and with his hospital closing, the only logical place for him is at Gaffney.

I have a special interest in children with speech difficulties, so I found this case one of the most compelling of the hour.

The moment when Zoey woke up and initially couldn’t speak was equally frightening and tear-inducing. Thank goodness she got her medical miracle a minute later, even if these types of miracles are somewhat of a tired TV trope.

Frost smiling at a patient who is using his stethoscope on Chicago Med S10 E1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr.)

Frost’s consultation with Abrams provided some much-needed comic relief in an otherwise heavy episode.

Abrams: Dr. Frost? I’m Dr. Abrams.

Frost: Pleasure to meet you.

Abrams: I imagine so. Can we talk in private?

[They move over]

Abrams: I reviewed the MRI images you sent me, and you were right. The patient has a large glioma tumor on her Brocha’s area.

Frost: So that would explain the sudden speech issues.

Abrams: Yes. That’s why I said you were right. I can say it again, if you’d like.

Abrams was as delightfully arrogant as always, but when push came to shove, he did the surgery and took care of the patient, so who can complain about that?

Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 Introduced A New Power Struggle

Archer And Lenox Butted Heads The Whole Episode

Archer’s got a new enemy, and we’re here for it.

Parenthood‘s Sara Ramos played Caitlin Lenox perfectly. She’s young, energetic, and determined to reform the hospital.

In short, she’s everything Jack Dayton should have been when he was the new hospital owner: someone with new ideas who is going to turn everything upside down.

Caitlin Lenox standing and looking into the camera on Chicago Med S10 E1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr.)

Unlike Dayton, though, Lenox is actually a doctor, so she understands something about medical care and how hospitals ought to be run.

I’m not sure how I feel about her firing Zach after knowing him for less than a day.

Zach has never had a major role, so I was excited that he finally got something substantial to do on Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1, only for him to lose his job by the end of the hour.

I was also surprised that Sharon signed off on it so easily, but she did say at the top of the hour that Gaffney would need to make major changes because of the influx of patients from Jackson closing.

Whether or not Zach is truly finished at Gaffney, Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 proved that Archer is a character desperately in need of therapy.

Archer: You’re military.

Lenox: Army. 

Archer: I guess that counts.

Lenox: You?

Archer: Navy.

Maggie: Okay… this has been fun, but I need a decision.

He can’t stand Lenox’s youth, energy, or insistence on running the ED her way, and things are only going to get worse for him as time goes on.

Ripley standing in the elevator in a defensive pose on Chicago Med S10 E1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr.)

The Pawel Story Needs To Go

Now That We Know The Truth Let’s Wrap This One Up

The Pawel nonsense took a back seat, for the most part, and at the end of the hour, Ripley explained to Hannah what had happened.

It was a meta performance since he was catching the audience up, but it worked.

Unsurprisingly, Ripley’s innocent. Sully and his friends beat up Pawel, and Ripley arrived too late to stop them.

Great. Now that we know, let’s wrap this up so we can move on to better stories for Ripley. I enjoyed his work with patients and would hate for that to be interrupted by any legal nonsense.

Similarly, I’m not sad to see LiIliana go.

Dr. Charles standing at a desk about to sign something on Chicago Med S10 E1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr)

Her leaving over Charles’ refusal to believe Pawel’s lies is somewhat of a split for the sake of drama, but it wraps up a relationship that has been mostly annoying, so that’s fine.

Dr. Charles was one of the MVPs on Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1, and I’d rather there be more of him in a medical capacity and less relationship nonsense.

As usual, he knew how to get through to a scared patient when no one else could.

This woman was carrying a heavy burden because of the fear of losing her son and her anger at her husband’s non-involvement in rescuing the boy in the first place.

Charles’ typical ability to listen and talk non-judgmentally helped her see she was acting out of fear when she was refusing to allow her son to have surgery. Well done!

Chicago Med's Naomi wearing latex gloves and staring straight ahead
(NBC/George Burns, Jr.)

This Story Bodes Well For The Future

Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 Set Up High Expectations and Planted Story Seeds

Not every episode of Chicago Med can be a high-stakes, mass-casualty event. That would get exhausting after a while.

But Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1 had a lot of work to do, and a high-stakes story was the right way to do it. In one fell swoop, this episode:

  • Introduced new characters
  • Wrote out two characters (assuming Zach is really gone.)
  • Set up conflicts that will last throughout the season
  • Set up the overarching plot of the hospital being overwhelmed with patients and needing to make changes

New showrunner Allen MacDonald also demonstrated his understanding of the characters and the kind of stories Chicago Med fans love.

He hit it out of the park, proving that long-time fans can trust him to lead the series in the right direction.

Archer checking a monitor during surgery on Chicago Med S10 E1
(NBC/George Burns, Jr)

Over to you, Chicago Med fanatics.

What did you think of Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1? Did it meet your expectations?

Rate Chicago Med Season 10 Episode 1!
×

Hit the comments with your thoughts.

Chicago Med airs on NBC on Wednesdays at 8/7c and on Peacock on Thursdays.

Watch Chicago Med Online

Jasmine Blu

Saturday 28th of September 2024

I, too, adored Marcel. He was probably one of the few remaining characters I still connected with a great deal.

That said, I'm all-in on Frost. He's a bit arrogant, and I rolled my eyes at him trying to bat his eyes and charm (but also it reminded me too much of the actor's previous role), but he quickly won me over by being genuinely passionate and compassionate regarding his patients.

I look forward to seeing him evolve this season. And thank the TV gods for Darren Barnet getting to play someone age-appropriate. He feels believable as a character here.

I like Lenox (although, I struggled with her firing Zach). But I also just enjoy Ramos, so there's that. Archer having an issue with her being young made me shake my head, but their tension is going to be so entertaining, I can already tell.

I need them to just focus on Charles in his profession. He's best there, and anything else that distracts from that bores me to tears or grinds my gears.

Also, I need them to do something, anything else with Ripley. Hopefully, this is the end of that storyline and we can move forward.

I actually really enjoyed this episode, and Med is usually my least fave of the One Chicago franchise. I feel like this season, I may actually watch weekly rather than letting them pile up and sporadically mini-bingeing. I still miss Marcel, though. But I didn't feel his absence as much as I thought I would, thank goodness.

Jasmine Blu

Monday 30th of September 2024

@The Observer, Oh, I totally get that! Although, the early days of Med were strongly the same with Manstead and all of that. Good lord that ship used to get on my nerves! April and Ethan were a rollercoaster, too.

The relationships on Fire and PD can definitely bog down the series a great deal. I never hid my annoyance with Upstead monopolizing everything on PD, and Fire's romances are a merry-go-round that gives me whiplash. But, for me, I also like that they're very character-centric, too. I feel like I get to know and connect with many of the characters in Fire and PD while also following the cases/emergencies of the week.

For whatever reason, I always had a hard time connecting with many of the characters on Chicago Med, and it got progressively worse as the series went on and became a revolving door of characters who typically disappeared by the time I actually remembered their names. However, Med does work the best as actual procedural that's more case-centric, and out of the medical dramas, it has an edge because of that, which I can appreciate.

I have a similar issue with the FBIs. My ranking is FBI, FBI Most Wanted, and FBI: International mostly because I have a harder time connecting with most of the International characters, but Most Wanted has tried my patience since the second season, so they're about neck and neck, honestly.

Thanks so much! I appreciate that! And I, too, love it when I get to read different perspectives about shows I enjoy. It's half the fun! :)

The Observer

Monday 30th of September 2024

@Jasmine Blu, Interesting because I prefer Med over Fire and especially PD which are basically soap operas of distracting relationships. Med sticks more to the medicine much more so than the other series stick to their professions. However it is interesting to read the well articulated views of someone who thinks differently than me. I always enjoy your reviews.

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!