(At Mike's place after Oliver has played the tape of Karl and Susan talking) Susan: Okay, ahm, first of all it was not the best sex I ever had. I just said that to make him feel better. Obviously, you are the best sex I ever had. Oliver: That explains the punch in the face. Mike: I'm gonna hit you again if you don't shut up. Susan: I know that this looks bad- Mike: You were actually fooling around with Karl behind Edie's back. Susan: No, no, no. No, Karl lied to me. He told me that he and Edie had split up before- Mike: You know what? I don't even care.
Susan: I've never stopped caring about you. Mike: Then why did you jump in bed with Karl? Susan: I would have never even gone there if I thought there was a chance with us. You just closed the door so completely, I- Can we just not talk about him? Have some more pie. (She feeds him) I know you like pie. I know you like me.