Meg: But Dad, I still don't understand that whole Immaculate Conception thing. How can anyone get pregnant without having sex?
Peter: Oh, there's lots of stories of that, Meg. Cleveland's got a cousin who had 8 girlfriends get pregnant, and he says he's not responsible for a single one.

• Permalink: But Dad, I still don't understand that whole Immaculate Concepti...
• Added: December 23, 2012

Magic baby? What does he do? Card tricks? Rabbit in the hat? Will he let someone in the audience punch him in the stomach? I'd like to punch a baby in the stomach.

Carter

• Permalink: Magic baby? What does he do? Card tricks? Rabbit in the hat? Wil...
• Added: December 23, 2012

Brian: (as Robbie) I think I might hang out in the town square. I hear an oracle from Greece is sending a funny message and I wanna be there when it arrives.
Messenger: (running in and gasping for air) Penis.
Brian: Heh.

• Permalink: I think I might hang out in the town square. I hear an oracle fr...
• Added: December 23, 2012

(as Joseph) Come on, this is our seventh date! It's completely natural! Birds do it! Bees do it! Dinosaurs whom we live alongside do it!

Peter

• Permalink: Come on, this is our seventh date! It's completely natural! Bird...
• Added: December 23, 2012

(narrating) And so Mary and Joseph began their courtship. But even after several dates, Jospeh couldn't get to first base. Not just because Mary was a virgin, but because baseball would not be invented for 1800 years and no one knew what the hell he was talking about.

Peter

• Permalink: And so Mary and Joseph began their courtship. But even after sev...
• Added: December 23, 2012

Peter: (as Joseph) Oh my God, look at that body. Can't you just imagine her standing on people's front lawns inside a cut-in-half bathtub?
Brian: (as Robbie) You should go talk to her and see if she can talk.

• Permalink: Oh my God, look at that body. Can't you just imagine her standin...
• Added: December 23, 2012

(as Joseph) So I went to see that new Oedipus play last week. Took my mother. Talk about an awkward ride home. Barely got a goodnight kiss.

Peter

• Permalink: So I went to see that new Oedipus play last week. Took my mother...
• Added: December 23, 2012

Peter: It's the greatest story ever told, Meg. A story that goes back over 100 years.
Chris: Yay, Star Wars!
Peter: No, Chris. It's the story of Christmas and the Immaculate Conception. You guys were born the dirty way. Now gather around, everybody, and hear the awe-inspiring tale that's caused millions and millions of deaths!

• Permalink: It's the greatest story ever told, Meg. A story that goes back o...
• Added: December 23, 2012

Chris: A guy's name was Robbie back then?
Peter: The Bible's fuzzy on that.

• Permalink: A guy's name was Robbie back then? The Bible's fuzzy on that.
• Added: December 23, 2012

Meg: I can only imaging what it was like for them on that very first Christmas.
Brian: Yeah, it was probably very moving. And fictional.
Stewie: Jesus lived with us for like a week, what else do you need?

• Permalink: I can only imaging what it was like for them on that very first ...
• Added: December 23, 2012