Grace: Olive just doesn't do well with change, and she's had a lot of it lately.
Ben: Like suddenly having a dad back in the picture, and one who doesn't know what a romper is.

• Permalink: Like suddenly having a dad back in the picture, and one who doesn't know what a romper is.
• Added: October 15, 2018

Ben: So this guy...do you love him?
Grace: I love you, Ben. I never stopped. Not for a moment. Not for five and a half years.

• Permalink: I love you, Ben. I never stopped. Not for a moment. Not for five and a half years.
• Added: October 09, 2018

Cal: But I'm glad you like him. He's pretty cool.
Olive: Yeah, he's okay. But you and me, it's us against the world. Twins rule.
Cal: Twins rule.

• Permalink: Twins rule.
• Added: October 09, 2018

Cal: He was my best friend! And now, you and he are...I don't even know what you're doing.
Olive: Cal, he wasn't your best friend. I was. All right. I still am.
Cal: Because you're my twin? How are we even twins anymore? Look at me.

• Permalink: Because you're my twin? How are we even twins anymore? Look at me.
• Added: October 09, 2018

Olive: All right, I know you're not used to it, Dad, but I'm allowed to see my boyfriend.
Ben: Not in the middle of the night you're not!

• Permalink: Not in the middle of the night you're not!
• Added: October 09, 2018

Don't waste your miracle on your pain. You deserve better.

Jared [to Michaela]

• Permalink: Don't waste your miracle on your pain. You deserve better.
• Added: October 09, 2018

Rob: This is gonna sound insane, but I'm a little protective of Danny. [pause] Kind of seems like you're cheating on him. [Grace scoffs] Sorry.
Grace: No. Honestly...it feels a little that way for me too.

• Permalink: No. Honestly...it feels a little that way for me too.
• Added: October 09, 2018

Ben: A calling. Like a voice in her head.
Michaela: What if that's it, Ben? What if this 'calling' got her killed?

• Permalink: What if that's it, Ben? What if this 'calling' got her killed?
• Added: October 09, 2018

Michaela: Ben, it is noticeable enough that we are fifteen miles outside my jurisdiction, let alone with my *civilian* brother in tow.
Ben: Your civilian brother who helped you find two kidnapped girls. The cops were useless without us.
Michaela: That does not make you a detective all of a sudden!

• Permalink: That does not make you a detective all of a sudden!
• Added: October 08, 2018

Ben: There has to be an explanation.
Michaela: And God's not good enough for you?
Ben: God's a catchall for things people don't understand. Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. We just...need more information.

• Permalink: God's a catchall for things people don't understand. Any sufficiently advanced technology is...
• Added: October 02, 2018

Ben: Don't want to talk about it.
Michaela: Why? Because then you'd have to admit that something miraculous is going on here?

• Permalink: Why? Because then you'd have to admit that something miraculous is going on here?
• Added: October 02, 2018

Olive: I knew Cal wasn't dead.
Ben: You did?
Olive: I don't know if it was some kind of twin thing, but I could -- I could feel him, alive...

• Permalink: I don't know if it was some kind of twin thing, but I could -- I could feel him, alive...
• Added: October 02, 2018