A sword-wielding assailant stabs a man with a suitcase and steals it. Batwoman is unable to stop her escape.
Luke tells Batwoman he needs her to leave him alone.
Roman and Safiyah are visiting, discussing their plans. She wants to use Circe but he refuses, showing her the ad campaign Circe will star in. He tells her that Alice helped give her the face back. Safiyah reveals to him that Alice is Beth Kane, Kate's twin.
Batwoman finds another victim of the sword assailant. When she fights her, she realizes it's Tatiana.
Mary and Ryan discover the dead man had been blinded by Circe Sionis.
Alice and Jacob kidnap Circe, run her DNA, and prove that she is Kate. Ocean brings a bag of items to job Kate's memories. Alice manages to breakthrough but then they are attacked by False Faces. Tatiana takes Alice. Kate escapes and finds Batwoman.
The False Faces take Jacob to Roman and it turns out that they are GCPD and they arrest him as an accomplice to Alice.
Kate doesn't recognize Mary but does recognize Sophie. In her head, Circe overpowers Kate and then Kate attacks Mary who jabs her with a knock-out syringe.
Luke sits down at a poker game with Tavaroff and John Diggle. Luke takes Tavaroff for everything and humiliates him. Tavaroff tries to take him out in the alley but Diggle intervenes. He talks to Luke and then Luke sees the Bat Signal.
Luke helps track down Alice and Safiyah so that Batwoman can offer her the Desert Rose plant in exchange. Safiyah accepts but hints Alice won't get everything.
Alice goes looking for Ocean, killing Tatiana along the way. She finds Ocean dead.
Kate escapes Sophie and demands the truth from Roman.