Kitty continues her stay in Ojai, trying to reinvent herself, when she meets a handsomely rugged handyman, Jack. As Kitty fakes her persona to seem like a local, she winds up in a situation that proves that honesty usually is the best policy.

They go on a first date after she lies about being a city girl, but after it goes poorly, decide to go on a second date anyway, just because.

Meanwhile, the rest of the Walkers are in on a little surprise birthday celebration for Sarah; what they all don't know is that Sarah has been lying to Luc about her age to appear younger... It's hard to keep up with the truth!

Sarah and Nora actually consider plastic surgery, as if that would ever happen, and after Luc knew her age all along, and Saul tells Nora she's perfect the way she is, everybody's happy again. Nora even quits that flower shop.

Finally, Justin and Rebecca attempt to patch things up, only not really. We know Emily VanCamp is out so it feels somewhat useless to even go through the motions. Holly also doesn't remember Rebecca, and runs away at the end of the episode.

David calls 911. Cliffhanger ensues.