Buffy has a prophetic dream. She dreams of Willow with a monkey, Joyce, and Drusilla staking Angel.
Buffy goes to Angel to make sure he's alright. She's worried that her dreams will come true, but he reassures her that not everything in the dream is accurate. They make-out and dispel any worries.
Angel and Buffy allude to the interest of wanting to sleep with each other.
Buffy shares the situation with Willow. Buffy thinks she will do it with Angel. She encourages Willow to ask Oz out and go for it.
Oz asks Willow out on a date. She agrees.
Xander asks Cordelia out on an official date, but she brushes it off.
The Scoobies are planning a surprise party for Buffy. Buffy tells her friends that she had the prophetic dream the night before.
Spike is confined to a wheelchair while he recuperates. He and Drusilla are planning a special return of a dangerous demon.
One part of Buffy's dream comes true: Joyce accidentally drops her plate and utters the same words in the dream.
A man visits Sunnydale High to chat with Jenny. It turns out that Jenny is pretending to be a computer teacher; she is actually a gypsy sent to watch Angel to make sure that the curse stays in tact.
Jenny takes Buffy away to pick up some books but they notice a vampire stealing a giant box. Buffy starts fighting the vampires; they burst through the wall of The Bronze into her surprise party.
Oz learns for the first time that vampires exist in Sunnydale.
The box that the vampires were stealing held a demon's arm. The arm belonged to The Judge, a powerful demon who when reassembled could destroy all. Jenny urges Angel to take the arm and leave Sunnydale; they need to hide the arm so that no one will be able to find it.
Angel is about to board the ship and take the arm away. Angel gives Buffy a claddagh ring as a special gift for her birthday and because he cares about her. Vampires burst from the ship to fight them; Buffy is thrown in the water and Angel jumps in to save her.
Buffy has another prophetic dream of Drusilla killing Angel.
Drusilla, Spike and their vampire minions reassemble The Judge. He kills the nerdy vampire as he had too much humanity as a vampire who reads.
Buffy and Angel spy on Spike's hideout to see what happened with The Judge. They're spotted but captured. Before The Judge is able to kill Buffy, the two make an escape into the sewers.
Both Angel and Buffy head back to Angel's apartment to hide from the vampires. They kiss and begin to have sex. Afterwards, something strange happens and Angel runs out into the rain.