The next day is Valentine’s day. The group reminisce about their worst Valentine’s Day and Grayson tops it by telling them that that was the day his father died.
It drives Jules crazy that Grayson won’t open up to her. She tries to pry it open, but he won’t budge.
Trav’s girlfriend wants him to take a sexy picture of himself for her.
Just like the circle of loves passes around, the circle of anger swings back around. Laurie gets the guys to give their women what they want.
Grayson tells Jules about his father, but he cant. Andy takes Bobby out instead of Ellie and Trav tries and fails at taking a sexy picture for his girlfriend.
In the end of the episode, Grayson lets Jules in, Andy puts together a bonfire of all the neighbors Christmas decorations, and Trav gives his girlfriend the romantic yet weird picture. Everyone is happy except for Tom.