When Sally shows back up, Bret decides he wants to go after her as well.  Both Bret and Jermaine show up to her birthday party with homemade presents are in for a shock when they see who she chooses.

Flight of the Conchords
Episode Number:

Flight of the Conchords Season 1 Episode 5 Quotes

Jemaine: It's not a cleaning cupboard, it's an apartment. It's my studio apartment.
Murray: More like a "compartment."

Murray: Jermaine?
Jermaine: Present.
Murray: Bret?
Bret: Yep.
Murray: And Murray... yes, present, thank you... I'm always here anyway, I don't know why I bother with my line