Pat finds out that Courtney stole Justice Society of America items and that she distributed them to her friends.
He demands Courtney get them back and isn't happy that she went behind his back.
At first Courtney doesn't have the heart to ask her friends for the items back after seeing how happy they are, but when she finally gets up the nerve, they refuse.
Pat has a similar conversation with Rick, who also refuses to return the hourglass.
Courtney, Yolanda, Beth, and Rick then learn that the Gambler is attempting to hack a communications company and want to go after him.
While Courtney is hesitant at first, she later agrees.
However, during their first mission, the new JSA runs into Sportsmaster and Tigress, who are revealed to be Lawrence Crock and Paula Brooks, instead of the Gambler.
The new JSA is outmatched and in trouble until Pat arrives with STRIPE.
The new JSA learn Pat has more to offer than meets the eye, and Courtney realizes what Pat has been trying to tell her all along.
Pat agrees to train the new team.
Elsewhere, Mike participates in his school's science fair and tells Pat and Barbara not to come. However, he is pleased when Barbara shows up, nonetheless, and they bond.
Lastly, Icicle and Cameron celebrate Christine's birthday.