Oscar's softball team is preparing for a game when their best player Marcus Murphy arrives injured.
Felix offers to take his place and Oscar wants to find anyone else. Oscar relents and agrees to let him play.
The team celebrates their win at the bar. It turns out Felix is the one who drove in the winning run. Oscar is bitter and tells Felix he just got lucky.
Felix and Oscar play basketball at the gym and Felix beats Oscar. Oscar and Felix argue and Felix challenges Oscar to a decathlon.
Emily sells two pairs of her earrings to Murphy. She sells a bracelet online but mails it before she receives payment.
The first event is to lift a heavy barbell over their heads. Felix does it easily but Oscar falls over.
The second event is to throw a football into a net which Oscar easily wins.
Felix wins the gymnastics beams.
Oscar wins arm wrestling by sneezing into his hand, forcing Felix to forfeit.
To break the tie, they play ping pong at the bar.
Teddy begs Felix to let Oscar win or they'll never hear the end of it. Felix agrees and throws the game.
Oscar rubs it in Felxi's face that he won and Felix tells him that he let him win. They decide to settle it all by wrestling and they both end up with injuries. They make up while lying on the floor in pain.
Roy is angry because Murphy can't remember his name.