He may have gotten his happy ending with Elena, but could he really return for one final adventure to conclude the franchise? We would be down for it. Would you?

Valerie was not my favorite Heretic when she first appeared, but somewhere along the way, she became the most enthralling. Her backstory was heartbreaking and all she wanted was happiness. Could she somehow wind up working at the magic school as a teacher who knows a little too much about the past?

Jo may have already had an encore, but the person who came back was not the real Jo. What if Alaric found a way to bring his former love back to life for good? Wouldn't that be the perfect conclusion for his arc?