Skip to Content
Subscribe

Taylor Sheridan is Correct: Critics Have Become Irrelevant

To be clear, Taylor Sheridan didn’t outright say that today’s film and TV critics are irrelevant. That platitude belongs to Joe Rogan.

But Taylor left little doubt that Joe Rogan snatched the words from his mouth. This isn’t Podcast Fanatic; however, it’s TV Fanatic, and Taylor’s accession to those remarks is highly relevant and, as it happens, true.

Unfortunately, Taylor Sheridan is being lumped in with conservatism because everyone has to have a label nowadays, whether it makes sense or not.

Rip Takes Care of Danger - Yellowstone Season 1 Episode 7
(Emerson Miller – Paramount)

Since Yellowstone isn’t following the Disney formula, which resulted in brilliant artistic achievements such as The Acolyte and She-Hulk (heavy on the sarcasm), Taylor must be a dangerous right-winger.

The reality is far different, at least to anyone who actually watches Yellowstone or Taylor’s other notable achievements, like Sicario, Mayor of Kingstown, and Tulsa King. Taylor can be correct in his assertion and not be a Republican operative at the same time.

The Cultivated Intellective

It’s difficult to frame the lead-up to Tayler Sheridan’s comments without indulging in the political nature of the TV critic business. But I’ll get to that in a minute. Besides, it’s not always as overtly political as it seems.

In many cases, these studios are well aware that they are pushing out crap. However, with a fleet of critics ready to sacrifice themselves on the altar of the almighty ‘impressions rating,’ even the worst sewage scrapings to ever see the light of day have hope.

(Courtesy of Paramount)

“They’re confounded by its success. They can’t get their head around it. The New York Times has done multiple, multiple articles where they’re doing this essay on ‘How is this shit so popular?'”

-Taylor Sheridan on the Joe Rogan Podcast

Someone should produce a documentary on the bubble that many of the big-name, veteran critics live within. Sheridan correctly references the “disconnect” between the entertainment industry, the critics who fawn over the product, and the audience.

Once you’ve tasted caviar, it’s hard to return to frozen tilapia filets on Taco Tuesday. The ever-widening gulf between the critic and the audience is a device of their own making.

The problem with living inside a bubble is how easy it is to forget everything on the outside. Peripheral vision abdicates in favor of the tunnel point of view.

When a Rotten Tomatoes critic score of 85% is up against an audience score of 30%, never doubt the actuality of that. There is no contemplation, no self-introspection. There is only an astonishing lack of understanding as to why that 45% divide exists.

Professional Critics are Paid

Spotted Eagle - 1883 Season 1 Episode 10
(Emerson Miller/Paramount+ (C) 2022 MTV Entertainment Studios. All Rights Reserved.)

Honestly, there’s simply no getting around this one. Someone is paying the bills, and the critic’s value rides a social media wave.

The divisive nature of the time we live in doesn’t allow for deviations from the status quo. Independent thought holds little value in the coin of the realm.

Publishing an opinion that departs from the prodigy of the collective is one of the most effective ways to shut off the outflow of currency, no matter what side of the aisle one stands on. “Go along to get along,” as the old saying goes, mostly because it pays well.

Fortunately, audiences are far more up-to-speed with this methodology and vehemently disagree. So, if critical determinations rarely agree with the audience, forcing the audience to ignore them, what is the point of the critic?

Besides, no one is looking for Claudia Puig or Ben Mankiewicz to tip the scales on a movie-going decision. Most are jumping on YouTube and TikTok, catching word-of-mouth, or making a decision based on the trailer.

Jacob Doing Ranch Work - 1923 Season 1 Episode 8
(Emerson Miller/Paramount+ © 2022 Viacom International Inc. All Rights Reserved.)

No entity is more familiar with this than Walt Disney Studios. The disparity between audience and critical appraisal of Disney shows and movies is often massive. It’s doubtful there are any other studios with so many.

The audience, for the most part, can give two flips on what most critics think about Disney or Disney-backed productions.

The Cultural Divide

This is not about taking sides, at least not from the point of view of this author. For some, however, it is.

Critics are far too concerned with TV and film productions meeting some sort of cultural standard that changes like a chameleon from month to month rather than the worth and value of the product.

Unfortunately, we live in a time of divisiveness that spans oceans of philosophical, moral, cultural, and political seas. In the case of Taylor Sheridan, that cultural divide is undeservedly rubbing off on his creations.

Mike and Bunny S03E06 - Mayor of Kingstown
(Dennis P. Mong Jr./Paramount+)

Critics like to lump Yellowstone in with right-of-center thinking despite the fact that Yellowstone is far from a right-wing utopia. In fact, it’s rare to see a show that flows so well through the various aspects of both sides without overtly insulting either one.

Yellowstone is far from a Trey Parker and Matt Stone brainchild. Taylor Sheridan was very clear on this in a November 2022 interview:

“The show’s talking about the displacement of Native Americans and the way Native American women were treated, and about corporate greed and the gentrification of the West, and land-grabbing. That’s a red-state show?”

Anyone who watches Yellowstone with an open mind has to agree. There is simply no other solution. However, the powers that be and the film and TV critics they employ disagree in a big way.

Recent seasons seem to be changing some minds on that front, but the point about distrust of today’s critics remains. It doesn’t matter where the critic rating currently sits on the Tomatometer. The show will remain one of the most popular programs on the planet.

Demi Moore as Cami Miller and Rylie Rodriguez as Monty’s daughter
(Emerson Miller/Paramount+)

In fact, the level of ongoing popularity is even more astonishing, considering that Yellowstone lacks a solid, familiar home. Most newcomers to the show can’t figure out if it’s on Paramount Network, Paramount+, Peacock, CBS, or anywhere else.

An Airing of Grievances or Legitimate Criticism?

Of course, appearing on the Joe Rogan podcast is not going to change anyone’s opinion of Taylor Sheridan or the movies and shows he has and is working on.

This is despite the fact that Joe Rogan is more of a centrist than left or right. Unfortunately, with the masses being so divided, especially those in Hollywood versus rural and country America, “centrist” is ideologically right or left, depending on where people stand.

They seem to feel a need to judge any project by how is it looking at the lens through today’s new ‘question morality.’ What should we be making movies about? And you can make a s*****y movie about something they support, and they’re gonna support that movie.

-Taylor Sheridan on the Joe Rogan Podcast

As such, critics frequently lambast Yellowstone and several of Sheridan’s works for poor character arcs, ridiculous premises, extensive melodrama, and boring plots.

Rip Takes Care of Danger - Yellowstone Season 1 Episode 7
(Emerson Miller – Paramount)

If this is true, what does that say about the audience, especially when Yellowstone is breaking records each season?

Either Taylor Sheridan has a solid point, or millions and millions of viewers are highly melodramatic, with vapid minds for creativity and artistic appeal.

Here’s to thinking that the professional TV critic’s relevance amounts to little or nothing.

Do you feel like critics are still relevant today? Will Taylor Sheridan become a pariah, or will his projects continue to be successful? Let us know what you think in the comments!

What are your thoughts about critics these days?
×

Watch Yellowstone Online

Logan Devendeer

Tuesday 5th of November 2024

It certainly has its merits. Before, critics were considered experts in the craft, knowing what was needed for something to be actual art and what was just, for example, a transformers-like movie - something you watch to have fun and not worry about its artistic values. And they had a much bigger reach due to writing in newspapers or showing up on tv, so their opinion was the only one in town for most people. Now, everyone's opinion is displayed everywhere, and it is a lot easier to find someone you actually like and trust through other means.

Nowadays, though, experts are considered people who have a side, and usually a woke one. For something to be good in the opinion of many, it has to check several boxes that most people just do not care about, and it is very easy to see it. As an example, the demands of the Oscars that this minimum number of minorities has to work behind the cameras, so many actors and actresses of one race or another have to be on screen or they wouldn't be considered for the prize, actual story be damned. It becomes clear they (in this example, oscars and critics) are not seeing the story for its merits, but letting outside issues guide their judgement... which might be quite good for activists and people who live off this drama, but for regular viewers it just loses all trust on their word.

And it doesn't help that, similar to what Carissa said in a comment in another piece, it feels less like simply the critic's opinion and more like the critic considering himself or herself above other people, pointing his or her finger at you and chastising the audience for all your allegeded misgivings and "wrong" opinions. I also remember reading a reviewer on another site saying to a comment that was complaining about token characters in a drama, ones that had no real story or arch for them but just be there to be seen by some metric, that "If you don't understand the need for inclusivity then there is no point in talking"... and whether you believe there is a need for it or not, when you shut down discussions by saying something like that, which was not even the point of the comment in the first place and there was actually common ground about the complaint and the need for actual inclusivity (and not tokenism as if often happens), you only strengthen the side that does not agree with you.

Some people might say that modern audiences demand such things, but as was mentioned here, when critics give a 9 to a show and the audience a 2 or 3, sometimes less, there is a clear divide in that - which reflects in how many are cancelled after a single season.

Thomas

Sunday 24th of November 2024

@Logan Devendeer, I would love to see more transparency in the industry in terms of who is paying the bills. Someone is always accusing critics of being paid and I'm sure there's some merit to the claims at times. To be fair, Sheridan gets hammered by some critics for his work, so he's bound to have some animosity. It's hard to blame him. As far as diversity and box-checking, I think the industry does a disservice to some by using them to check a box. Especially when you look at The Expanse, which is a fantastic show and one of the most diverse out there. Just make a good story and the rest will fall into place. It's proof that forced diversity is wholly unnecessary. There are great actors and actresses out there of every stripe and they will always do well if the story is worth the audience's time.

Carissa Pavlica

Tuesday 5th of November 2024

We had a bit of a kerfluffle here on TVF because some people disagreed with one of our editorial opinion pieces. I was being called out as a poor editor for letting someone share their opinion on a topic. That's something I'll never do for all the reasons you pointed out. Conversation and understanding all sides is imperative. Once debate is silenced, nobody learns anything. Everyone needs to be honest and speak from their hearts, not write to impress a specific audience. Although, here at TVF, we tend to cover what we like far more often that what we don't, which has its own set of challenges. We'll get there some day! Again, thanks so much for our insightful comments. I love a good conversation!

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!