Skip to Content

The Pitt Is Damn Near Perfect But a Slight Change Could be Game-Changing

The advent of streaming has changed the television game.

The rules that have held the medium together have been bent, broken, and changed.

The Pitt is one of those shows that changes the game, setting the bar for others in the genre.

(John Johnson/Max)

Sometimes, passing that bar becomes impossible, but when other shows catch on, a new style is born.

On the surface, the show is not doing anything new. Medical dramas have become increasingly popular, especially in the past decade and a half.

However, these dramas are almost exclusively made by broadcast networks, and the rules differ there.

The Pitt is the first medical procedural made with streaming in mind, and that becomes stark in the final product. 

The Pitt Season 1 chronicles the events of one shift in a busy public hospital in Pittsburgh. Every episode covers one hour of the shift.

This format has not been done before in other medical shows, as they take place over months and years, elevating The Pitt above everyone else.

Robby explains to Helene and Jeremy that Spencer has a DNR. (Warrick Page/MAX) (Warrick Page/Max)

Every episode feels tight and urgent, which is what one would want to feel in a show like this.

It is elevated by near-perfect performances from cast members led by Noah Wyle.

Every cast member strives to be on the same level as their counterparts; thus, no one drags the episode down.

While it’s not shot Succession-style, the seamless transition from one character to another can make it feel like it is filmed in a single take, like Netflix’s current darling Adolescence.

The Pitt has a lot going for it, but that can be negated by how quickly everything ends.

Every Episode of The Pitt Feels Like It Ends After Ten Short Minutes

(Warrick Page/Max)

The show manages to hold viewers from the first scene to the last.

Max must be ecstatic about its analytics if things like “active engagement duration” are metrics they consider.

Everything melts into each other smoothly as storylines are organically picked up without feeling like they missed a beat.

It is so engaging that when the credits roll, I’m confident many viewers are left asking, “Is that it?

Keeping up with how different the show feels, the way episodes end always leaves some begging for more.

(Warrick Page/Max)

The Pitt is not the first show by any means to master this, but while others go for a cliffhanger that makes you think, “I can’t wait for next week,” The Pitt makes you wish you could get it immediately!

And now comes the controversial part.

The Pitt Would Work Best As a Binge Release

The jury’s still out on binge versus weekly releases.

Both models have strengths and weaknesses, and arguments can be made for each. However, viewers can agree that it depends on how the show is made.

While I do love my 22-episode shows, I’m not spending 15 hours watching Maggie and OA run around New York doing more of the same.

However, I’ll gladly watch The Pitt for 15 hours because the format just works.

(Bennett Raglin/CBS)

The fact that the season takes place in one shift should be the best indicator that it should be binged for maximum effect.

Taking these weekly breaks does it a disservice. If you’ve ever experienced the high of engaging with a good TV show, movie, or song, then you understand what I’m aiming for.

The Pitt feels like a show you think about for weeks because it is that stimulating.

On the other side are proponents of weekly releases. The biggest argument is that TV needs time to grow and find its audience. Weekly conversations around an episode draw more attention to it.

(Warrick Page/Max)

This is a great argument, and it has been proven accurate time and time again, but it doesn’t always hold true.

Nowadays, people watch what’s trending on their streaming homepage, which can also draw more attention to a TV show.

What’s the Happy Medium?

Many platforms have tried to find a perfect formula for releasing TV shows. Some go for multi-episode season premieres and then weekly releases.

Others release multiple episodes weekly, while some might do one episode per week and then a multi-episode season finale.

(Warrick Page/Max)

Clearly, there is no winning formula. Shows can fall off between weeks or soar. But since The Pitt takes place in one day, Max should try something new for Season 2.

It should capture viewers for three hours every week for three weeks and then overwhelm them with six hours in the final week.

That would allow storylines to be discussed for several weeks while not robbing viewers of an immersive viewing experience.

But that’s just a suggestion.

Over to you, The Pitt Fanatics. What do you love most about the show? Are you okay with weekly episodes or saving them for a binge?

Chime in in the comments.

Watch The Pitt Online

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.

Robin Altman

Tuesday 1st of April 2025

my ONLY problem with the show, is that because its not binged, and we're only getting one episode at a time.... I tend to forget that these are still 1st day interns! After 6 weeks I found myself arguing with the tv "you should know how to do that by now" (when in fact, they've only been at the job for 1/2 of a day!.) Alternatively, while I've sat glued to these shooting episodes, now that I've finally caught on that these interns are STILL newbies... it seems they were given a lot of autonomy to treat the victims, while still having no experience. As as a dedicated medical drama viewer, its hard for me to make that transition, when on Greys, the "new" interns are still in their 1st year, while I'm 3 years on. (btw... this has been the Grey's formula since the beginning -- 3 years = 1 year - more or less). I can't compare to ER, which I never watched, because at the time I chose Chicago Hope, and my VCR/Cable set up had limitations. But everyone says this has been a natural progression for Noah Wyle. He's brilliant in this role. Someday I'll watch ER also.

Denis

Monday 7th of April 2025

@Jasmine Blu, Will definitely pick your brain about ER after I start.

I grew tired of the constant mysteries without any answers. It was the same problem FROM has been starting to run into. I knew people disliked the direction it went but I wasn't expecting to start hating it in Season 2.

Jasmine Blu

Wednesday 2nd of April 2025

@Denis, I never watched ER either, and it's definitely next up for me to watch probably after The Pitt is over. It's one of those legacy shows I never experienced, but now's as good a time as any to tune in.

I watched Lost when it was on, and I do recall it started to lose traction along the way. In hindsight, I'm convinced that the BTS drama impacted the show a great deal as it wasn't a great set to work on.

Denis

Tuesday 1st of April 2025

@Carissa Pavlica, I've also never watched ER but I'm planning on watching this summer. Been looking for a good show with many seasons but after two seasons of Lost going nowhere I gave up.

Denis

Tuesday 1st of April 2025

@Robin Altman, I didn't catch that but that's a good one. I always expect interns to be interns for at least five years before I let them go.

Carissa Pavlica

Tuesday 1st of April 2025

I think the urgency of the situation wiped away all the safety net of them being monitored. It was a sink or swim situation, not unlike what Abbott likely experienced in the service. It forced them to toss aside their fears and confidently embrace their skills because to do otherwise would mean a life. I think it's a brilliant way for them to dive in head first.

You have never seen ER? Oh my word. I rewatched it a couple of years ago, and it still holds up. Your summer viewing is set!

Denis

Monday 31st of March 2025

Okay, everyone wants weekly releases, but can we agree that the episodes need to be longer?

Denis

Tuesday 1st of April 2025

@Jasmine Blu, Huzzah!

Jasmine Blu

Monday 31st of March 2025

I stand firm on the weekly releases, but I definitely agree the episodes need to be longer. When you're on streaming, you can go big. I want every last minute, don't give us shortened hours like you're on network. Every last second.

pedja

Friday 28th of March 2025

"The fact that the season takes place in one shift should be the best indicator that it should be binged for maximum effect."

I disagree. '24' had weekly episodes, and that worked just fine.

One season = one shift concept of 'The Pitt' is genius, and weekly episodes, by some magic seamlessly 'flowing' one into another, without missing a beat, is an amazing experience, but I don't think I could 'survive' binge watching the whole season at once, one can cry his eyes out only so much :) And it would take away the experience, IMHO.

Only 'flaw' of 'The Pitt' as of now is that episodes aren't really an hour long :)

Hopefully MAX knows that they have something special here, so will green-light, say, next 5 seasons?, for starters.

Denis

Monday 31st of March 2025

@pedja, idk 24 was made for broadcast so it worked. I tried binge-watching and it wasn't the same.

I nearly tapped out during the mass casualty episode so I understand how overwhelming it can be.

Jasmine Blu

Saturday 29th of March 2025

@pedja, I already watch every episode leaned forward like I'm waiting for someone to direct ME to do something. I've responded verbally to things like they're talking to me directly. I find this show so immersive that I can't imagine bingeing it all on one sitting.

I appreciate that it's one of the few series that exists where we're all in it together at the same time. And there's always so much to dissect and mull over.

On the one hand, it being one shift and consuming that all at once adds to how fast-paced that shift is and adds even more to the grittiness and realism. But on the other hand, I really love examining things at the same time and allowing the necessary conversations to happen between each episode. It's more impactful.

Huda

Thursday 27th of March 2025

Dropping all the eps, or even a few eps at once will dilute the conversations around it. Part of the joy of a weekly show is the consistent engagement in the post-ep discussions, and having the pause in between episodes allows viewers to allow scenes to percolate, to go back and rewatch and be able to discuss in more depth. Drop more/ all episodes at the same time, and you have people watching at different paces, and you'll lose that critical discussion mass as folks don't want to be spoiled. Would Max want that?

Also, in some ways, the frenetic quality of each hour of The Pitt works against packing them together. For me, as great as it is, each hour already packs so much that it would be a health hazard (lol) if I'm forced to watch several hours at a time!

Denis

Monday 31st of March 2025

@Huda, I know that's a strong argument but it doesn't necessarily hold true for streaming shows. Conversations go on for weeks on end as people discover new takes on social media or with their friends.

I understand how overwhelming it can be to some but I want to be overwhelmed lol. That way I understand how Robby is feeling in that moment.

Carissa Pavlica

Thursday 27th of March 2025

You're my people!! I totally agree. Shows that release all episodes at once are a flash in the pan. I actually forget that I watched most of them! The Pitt deserves to be savored.

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!