The cast was left reeling at the outset of Bachelor in Paradise Season 2 Episode 4.
Mikey and Ashley I., for example, were left especially deserted and heartbroken after Jared asked Clare to be his date.
As for that burgeoning couple, they took a sailboard to a small island and went bungee jumping.
Meanwhile, Michael G. arrived with a date card and also with a mission: to win over Tenley, who was already torn between two other suites. Can you say LOVE SQUARE, people?!?
Also, on the evening of the cocktail party, Jonathan and Mikey attempted to convince Juelia that Joe is playing her.
Indeed, craziness abounded this week. Catch up with it all when you watch Bachelor in Paradise online via the video above.