Ambrose is locked and tortured by the Weird Sisters, Hilda tries to see him but they trick her, which she expects and sneaks in bones for Ambrose to make a skelton key out of.

Meanwhile, with Sabrina being expelled she goes back to her actual high school. She finds out about Roz and tries to help, only for Roz and Harvey to accuse her of causing the blindess in the first place. She leaves to go home and ends up inviting a missionary who is actually a witch hunter.

The witch hunters attack and harm Ambrose, the Weird Sisters, and two other witches. They attack Sabrina with arrows and then she suddenly awakens. Her eyes are all white though and she is levitating and she kills two angels. Then she brings back everyone who died and Harvey catches her right before she comes back to her old self. 

Ms. Wardwell goes on a date with Adam that day, and he offers her an escape from Greendale. She is considering it during dinner until it is revealed that the Dark Lord found out through her familiar what she was planning to do to keep Adam safe. So the Dark Lord pretended to be Adam, while feeding her the real one that night over dinner.

Ms. Wardwell starts to make a plan after she connects the dots and realizes that the Dark Lord now won't know what is coming.