The X Factor Top 5 Results: Shocker! Comments (Page 2)
30 Comments
Miss Nessa
December 9th, 2011 10:40 AM
Last night Rachel Crow clearly out sang Marcus Canty. I should not have had to come to a dead lock. Paula as well as Nicole had to stand to their feet through out Rachel's performance. Nicole should have been true to herself however, Marcus will be leaving next week without a doubt. He is not in the league with the others.
Tomas
December 9th, 2011 10:36 AM
We have to remember that it is not to a singing contest. The show is in quest of a recording artist. Ask yourself which person is most marketable…. Which one can you see doing a commercial? That’s who they’re looking for. If they were looking for a good singer they got rid of most of them already! I would like to see Chris Renee because of his story and his writings or Astro because he’s just too cool to be the next recording artist and neither of them can sing very well. I do miss Astro (wish he was still in the competition)…. Good luck to the remaining contestants!
EMoonbeam
December 9th, 2011 10:24 AM
I never thought much off Rachel nor do I think much off Marcus or Melanie for that matter there music just doesn't really appeal to me there just like many other artists before them. After watching Rachels' reaction last night I think the right person did go she clearly wasn't as prepared to go as they all should be they have to be prepared knock backs only one person can win & she done well just to make it that far.
I've only been watching American X Factor for CHRIS RENE
Phyllis
December 9th, 2011 10:06 AM
Won't watch this show again, unfair, judgemental, needs at least two judges replaced. Love Idol dislike XFactor.
sloane
December 9th, 2011 9:32 AM
OMG! What a fixed show! How obvious it was and how stupidly it was played out! 10 seasons of american idol and now experiencing the X factor Please! Marcus SUCKS! how can you market marcus when he is just like the other zillion black male singers all the same age and the same boring package,he is NO Usher and cant sing worth a crap. How can you be in the bottom 2 the last 3 shows and survive that again ! Obviously Nicole KNEW or she would not have done that , tell me they dont know what america voted? as for being the bad guy, her ego would never let her be too damaged, and as far as not being the bad guy, she sunk her azz right in the bad guy seat ! Rachel was awesome,she deserved to stay there another week,I never knew what they ever saw in Marcus and all the others just like him, hes not even attractive,I keep trying to figure out any kinda angle with him and I simply dont get it , he should of gone along time ago! Pathetic Nicole deserved to get booed for being well such a Pussyca
Marie
December 9th, 2011 9:26 AM
I love Rachel crow, she didn't deserve to go home, I'm so angry at nichole, she should have sent Marcus home
Dan Forcella Rank: Staff Member
December 9th, 2011 9:14 AM
Yeah the fact of the matter is that America voted to send Rachel home. We all should not be hating on Nicole as much as we are, because in the end, Marcus was the one that the majority of people wanted to stay. The only reason I will come down on Nicole is because it was obvious that she thought Rachel was better. She thought Rachel was better and should have stayed, and just didn't want to be the one to send Marcus home, so she left it up to America. In this case it worked out for her, because America sided with her decision, but the point is that she didn't know that. In that situation, you have to go with the person you think should stay. Don't leave it up to America just because you don't want to be the bad guy.
-Dan
Jan
December 9th, 2011 9:11 AM
Nicole made this personal. She doesn't get along with Simon, so she didnT vote. Rachel was far more better than Marcus and Josh. If Nicole and Paula can't vote to send someone home, then they don't belong there.
If the rumors are true then Rachel won't be hurting after last nights debacle.
LA Reed.... UGH some of the stuff that comes out of that man's mouth.
Nicole.... Really? I love you Rachel and you deserve one more week but Marcus is so cute and he sings just to me..... So I'm gonna have to throw you under the bus but aren't I a beautiful crier while I do it?
Seriously will not watch another season of this. I haven't been able to really get behind any of the contestants. I'm so annoyed with the judges constant snide little attacks on each other. The format makes certain they have their favorites and will never vote against them. And I wonder if sometimes the judges aren't trying to sabotage one act in favor of one of the others.
Julia Mullenix
December 9th, 2011 9:03 AM
Rachel was 100% better than Marcus. He should have went home. But Nicole being the cry baby she is,could not vote. If she can't get with the program she needs to be replaced.
mr really
December 9th, 2011 8:04 AM
dont hate on the show. nicole did not send rachel home, america did. isn't this the purpose of the deadlock, that if any judge stronly believed in both contestant they have the option to opt out and let the public decide. dont forget simon also used the deadlock when he didn't want to make a dicision, so what, it was ok for him but not nicole. do as the show ask, go vote 5o times if possible if you want someone to stay, dont leave it up to the judges you may be surprise of the out come. have anyone consider that marcus may only be in the bottom 3 or 2 but he is not the bottom vote getter. aviously. continue watching.
Michelle
December 9th, 2011 1:59 AM
Guess what this show does not matter anymore without DREW!!!! Glad Rachel went home... not a Marcus fan but he is more of a package than Rachel IMO.
Nicole needs to be replaced. LA just needs to figure out how to not say the stupidest things!
ps of course he is not going to send home one of his on boys people!
Nedynchic
December 9th, 2011 12:55 AM
Nicole knows nothing abt music aside dancing. She's got nothing compared 2 Rachel. I think Nicole n L.A Reid r d mistakes if d season n shd b sent home alongside Marcus Canty next wk!
Bulls**t!!!!!
Zoey Parker
December 9th, 2011 12:53 AM
I am one of Rachel's fans. She was better than Marcus. And that was way, way obvious. Boo, Nicole!
gracieallan
December 9th, 2011 12:42 AM
I don't know who you are Dan Forcella, but you called it spot on. I do hope if X Factor is back next year, we find some reasonable replacements for L.A. and Nicole. I suggest they inform the new applicants for the position that they may at some point be asked to choose between two contestants. That apparently was not made clear to Nicole, who seemed very out of sorts that she should be called on to make such a decision (had anyone mentioned to her that she is a ...judge?).
Talacia
December 9th, 2011 12:12 AM
I am serious. This show has no wiggle room for error. Marcus, Nicole and LA need to be sent home. He is an egomaniac who is never wrong and Nicole couldn't judge to save her life and she is a freakin judge?!! Cheryl Cole looks better AND can do a better job. Marcus can't cut it and should have gone home. I'm done after this season if LA and Nicole arent gone
TVDiva
December 8th, 2011 11:23 PM
Yeah Nicole couldn't make up her mind so she left it up to america's votes. Rachel is talented and probably will be fielding telephone calls for work tomorrow. With time and age she will become an even better singer. Marcus is an entertainer... Yes his vocals could be stronger at times but lets be real when we look at this field they are suppose to be elite.
Mike
December 8th, 2011 10:50 PM
LA sucks he needs to look out for the performers and do the right thing after all he is affecting lives, all he does is knock on the other mentors acts and his acts can't do anything wrong. That's a bunch of crap he thinks it's a competition ad him agaist the other mentors and don't even think about the better acts getting sent home. And Nichol needs to go she needs to do the right thing also everyone knows she screwed up tonight do not doing what even she knew was right and send Marvus home. If LA or nichol is on this show next season myself and alot of others I know won't be watching this show. I'm sorry I started watching it I guess I was a fool for believing it was a competition between contestants, and for now realizing it was a competition between mentors. I could go on all night but I believe anyone who watches this show sees what I see!!!
Bia
December 8th, 2011 10:34 PM
OMG, I really don't know what L.A. is doing in this show! He's like, the most competitive and unreasonable person, EVER! Marcus was, obviously, the weakest candidate, but L.A. can't stand to see one of his boys go down...
mary
December 8th, 2011 10:14 PM
I think Marcus should have went home. He was in the bottom 3 times already. That's obviously telling you something! Little cry baby couldn't make up her mind and send him home. He will not make it to the top 2. That's for sure. He will be in the bottom next week again......
December 9th, 2011 10:40 AM
Last night Rachel Crow clearly out sang Marcus Canty. I should not have had to come to a dead lock. Paula as well as Nicole had to stand to their feet through out Rachel's performance. Nicole should have been true to herself however, Marcus will be leaving next week without a doubt. He is not in the league with the others.
December 9th, 2011 10:36 AM
We have to remember that it is not to a singing contest. The show is in quest of a recording artist. Ask yourself which person is most marketable…. Which one can you see doing a commercial? That’s who they’re looking for. If they were looking for a good singer they got rid of most of them already! I would like to see Chris Renee because of his story and his writings or Astro because he’s just too cool to be the next recording artist and neither of them can sing very well. I do miss Astro (wish he was still in the competition)…. Good luck to the remaining contestants!
December 9th, 2011 10:24 AM
I never thought much off Rachel nor do I think much off Marcus or Melanie for that matter there music just doesn't really appeal to me there just like many other artists before them. After watching Rachels' reaction last night I think the right person did go she clearly wasn't as prepared to go as they all should be they have to be prepared knock backs only one person can win & she done well just to make it that far.
I've only been watching American X Factor for CHRIS RENE
December 9th, 2011 10:06 AM
Won't watch this show again, unfair, judgemental, needs at least two judges replaced. Love Idol dislike XFactor.
December 9th, 2011 9:32 AM
OMG! What a fixed show! How obvious it was and how stupidly it was played out! 10 seasons of american idol and now experiencing the X factor Please! Marcus SUCKS! how can you market marcus when he is just like the other zillion black male singers all the same age and the same boring package,he is NO Usher and cant sing worth a crap. How can you be in the bottom 2 the last 3 shows and survive that again ! Obviously Nicole KNEW or she would not have done that , tell me they dont know what america voted? as for being the bad guy, her ego would never let her be too damaged, and as far as not being the bad guy, she sunk her azz right in the bad guy seat ! Rachel was awesome,she deserved to stay there another week,I never knew what they ever saw in Marcus and all the others just like him, hes not even attractive,I keep trying to figure out any kinda angle with him and I simply dont get it , he should of gone along time ago! Pathetic Nicole deserved to get booed for being well such a Pussyca
December 9th, 2011 9:26 AM
I love Rachel crow, she didn't deserve to go home, I'm so angry at nichole, she should have sent Marcus home
Rank: Staff Member
December 9th, 2011 9:14 AM
Yeah the fact of the matter is that America voted to send Rachel home. We all should not be hating on Nicole as much as we are, because in the end, Marcus was the one that the majority of people wanted to stay. The only reason I will come down on Nicole is because it was obvious that she thought Rachel was better. She thought Rachel was better and should have stayed, and just didn't want to be the one to send Marcus home, so she left it up to America. In this case it worked out for her, because America sided with her decision, but the point is that she didn't know that. In that situation, you have to go with the person you think should stay. Don't leave it up to America just because you don't want to be the bad guy.
-Dan
December 9th, 2011 9:11 AM
Nicole made this personal. She doesn't get along with Simon, so she didnT vote. Rachel was far more better than Marcus and Josh. If Nicole and Paula can't vote to send someone home, then they don't belong there.
Rank: Extra
December 9th, 2011 9:09 AM
If the rumors are true then Rachel won't be hurting after last nights debacle.
LA Reed.... UGH some of the stuff that comes out of that man's mouth.
Nicole.... Really? I love you Rachel and you deserve one more week but Marcus is so cute and he sings just to me..... So I'm gonna have to throw you under the bus but aren't I a beautiful crier while I do it?
Seriously will not watch another season of this. I haven't been able to really get behind any of the contestants. I'm so annoyed with the judges constant snide little attacks on each other. The format makes certain they have their favorites and will never vote against them. And I wonder if sometimes the judges aren't trying to sabotage one act in favor of one of the others.
December 9th, 2011 9:03 AM
Rachel was 100% better than Marcus. He should have went home. But Nicole being the cry baby she is,could not vote. If she can't get with the program she needs to be replaced.
December 9th, 2011 8:04 AM
dont hate on the show. nicole did not send rachel home, america did. isn't this the purpose of the deadlock, that if any judge stronly believed in both contestant they have the option to opt out and let the public decide. dont forget simon also used the deadlock when he didn't want to make a dicision, so what, it was ok for him but not nicole. do as the show ask, go vote 5o times if possible if you want someone to stay, dont leave it up to the judges you may be surprise of the out come. have anyone consider that marcus may only be in the bottom 3 or 2 but he is not the bottom vote getter. aviously. continue watching.
December 9th, 2011 1:59 AM
Guess what this show does not matter anymore without DREW!!!! Glad Rachel went home... not a Marcus fan but he is more of a package than Rachel IMO.
Nicole needs to be replaced. LA just needs to figure out how to not say the stupidest things!
ps of course he is not going to send home one of his on boys people!
December 9th, 2011 12:55 AM
Nicole knows nothing abt music aside dancing. She's got nothing compared 2 Rachel. I think Nicole n L.A Reid r d mistakes if d season n shd b sent home alongside Marcus Canty next wk!
Bulls**t!!!!!
December 9th, 2011 12:53 AM
I am one of Rachel's fans. She was better than Marcus. And that was way, way obvious. Boo, Nicole!
December 9th, 2011 12:42 AM
I don't know who you are Dan Forcella, but you called it spot on. I do hope if X Factor is back next year, we find some reasonable replacements for L.A. and Nicole. I suggest they inform the new applicants for the position that they may at some point be asked to choose between two contestants. That apparently was not made clear to Nicole, who seemed very out of sorts that she should be called on to make such a decision (had anyone mentioned to her that she is a ...judge?).
December 9th, 2011 12:12 AM
I am serious. This show has no wiggle room for error. Marcus, Nicole and LA need to be sent home. He is an egomaniac who is never wrong and Nicole couldn't judge to save her life and she is a freakin judge?!! Cheryl Cole looks better AND can do a better job. Marcus can't cut it and should have gone home. I'm done after this season if LA and Nicole arent gone
December 8th, 2011 11:23 PM
Yeah Nicole couldn't make up her mind so she left it up to america's votes. Rachel is talented and probably will be fielding telephone calls for work tomorrow. With time and age she will become an even better singer. Marcus is an entertainer... Yes his vocals could be stronger at times but lets be real when we look at this field they are suppose to be elite.
December 8th, 2011 10:50 PM
LA sucks he needs to look out for the performers and do the right thing after all he is affecting lives, all he does is knock on the other mentors acts and his acts can't do anything wrong. That's a bunch of crap he thinks it's a competition ad him agaist the other mentors and don't even think about the better acts getting sent home. And Nichol needs to go she needs to do the right thing also everyone knows she screwed up tonight do not doing what even she knew was right and send Marvus home. If LA or nichol is on this show next season myself and alot of others I know won't be watching this show. I'm sorry I started watching it I guess I was a fool for believing it was a competition between contestants, and for now realizing it was a competition between mentors. I could go on all night but I believe anyone who watches this show sees what I see!!!
December 8th, 2011 10:34 PM
OMG, I really don't know what L.A. is doing in this show! He's like, the most competitive and unreasonable person, EVER! Marcus was, obviously, the weakest candidate, but L.A. can't stand to see one of his boys go down...
December 8th, 2011 10:14 PM
I think Marcus should have went home. He was in the bottom 3 times already. That's obviously telling you something! Little cry baby couldn't make up her mind and send him home. He will not make it to the top 2. That's for sure. He will be in the bottom next week again......