The X Factor Top 5 Review: Mesmerizing Melanie

by at . Comments

Just in case anyone was wondering, everyone faced the music yet again on The X Factor this week. The Final Five performed two songs, one dance hit and another chosen by the contestants.

How contrived was it the "they have one day to practice this song" bit, though? After the Pepsi songs didn't come through, they were given 24 hours to prepare another track? If it's their "Save Me" song, everyone but Marcus Canty should have it in the holster ready to go. 

Although the Chevy commercials in between the live performances were much, much better, let's still take a look at how the contestants did...

The X Factor Top 5

Melanie Amaro "Someone Like You" - Why would you waste such an epic song like this by turning into a dance beat for this week's theme? She was good, but it could have been a lot better.
My Score: 7/10

Marcus Canty "Ain't Nobody" - This took me back to the 80s and that's not a good thing. He did the song justice, but it did not feel organic whatsoever. Simon said that Melanie's wasn't karaoke. But his was.
My Score: 6/10

Rachel Crow "Nothin' on You" - Rachel chose her own song, and once again she chose correctly. This was a perfect upbeat performance, and her charm really puts her over the top. Other than L.A.'s slightly homophobic comment, it was all smiles.
My Score: 7/10

Josh Krajcik "We Found Love" - This really wasn't in Josh's wheelhouse, but he pulled it off the best he could. He gave the record new life, and I enjoyed it.
My Score: 6/10

Chris Rene "Live Your Life" - The dude just does it for me. Even though he was a bit overpowered by the backing track and singers during the hook, he absolutely murdered the verses, which was enough for me.
My Score: 8/10

Round One goes to Chris Rene.

Melanie Amaro "When You Believe" - She can take on any of the big divas whenever she wants. She never misses a note and has the power to back up her decisions. This was one of if not her best performance of the season.
My Score: 10/10

Melanie Amaro Top 5

Marcus Canty "A Song For You" - His range is fantastic, which was showcased here, but this performance was a bit boring. Paula was right in that he's a great story teller, but so was Simon in that no one should be jumping out of their chair.
My Score: 7/10

Rachel Crow "Music & Me" - Her lower register sounded downright awful through the first half of the song, which threw me through a bit of a loop. Luckily she lost the low parts midway through and killed the ending of it.
My Score: 8/10

Josh Krajcik "Something" - His faces in this performance were worth the price of admission. As far as the vocal, unlike what L.A. said, this was anything but karaoke. It sounded nothing like the original, and it was incredibly powerful.
My Score: 9/10

Chris Rene "Where Do We Go From Here?" - It was great to see the original song, and he sounded fantastic, but am I the only one who realized he only had about three different lines in a two minute song? There were way too many "yeah yeahs" and repeated phrases to call that a stroke of genius.
My Score: 8/10

Round Two goes to Melanie Amaro.

We are down to the nitty-gritty, as one more will go home tomorrow before next week's semifinals. I've seen too many of these shows to think that Marcus isn't the leading candidate to go home tomorrow after being in the bottom on a number of occasions already. I think either Josh or Rachel will join him there.

What do you all think, TV Fanatics? Who was the best of the night? And who will leave the stage tomorrow?  

TV Fanatics Love Prime Instant Video
Amazon Prime Instant Video
Catch Up on Old Episodes
of Similar Shows and Old Favorites.


Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Dan Forcella is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,

I'm going to be honest. Chris sucked. He can't sing, I love T.I.'s "Live Your Life" and he just ruined it. I liked "Hey Homie" but I think its sad Drew went home and Chris is up there singing that crap, and I didn't even like Drew's singing. Chris should go home this week based off of performances. Rachel slayed the first song, but the second song sounded Disney to me. She did okay, but I think her time will be up soon. Marcus, he owned the night. I don't like when he dances and sings, he just needs to sing. He's a church boy, sing and do nothing else. He's not Bobby Brown so just sing Marcus and you won't go wrong. Josh, hated the first song because it wasn't him. Rihanna and Josh don't mesh in my mind. The second song didn't wow me, but it was him and vocally he was good. Melanie. She.....well, she killed it. I loved Adele, though I don't agree with the song choice, but she did it justice. She redeemed herself with the second song because she killed it. I love that song from the Prince of Egypt and she did it as well as Whitney and Mariah, which is hard to do. I predict that Marcus will survive the week, but based off of performances I think Chris will finally know where to go after this week which is home.


Between Chris and the chubby Cuban lady. IDK...but if Marcus doesn't leave next Ill stop watching.