Sundays 10:00 PM on AMC
The-walking-dead

The Walking Dead Season 4 Report Card: B-

by at .  Updated at . Comments

Looking back on The Walking Dead Season 4, the divide between the first and last eight episodes really made it feel like two seasons.

Where the front half redid/ended the Governor storyline while the survivors fought a deadly cold, the back half focused on the characters, dealing with the fallout of the prison and the trek to Terminus.

With Scott M. Gimple's first crack at showrunner (who will return for The Walking Dead Season 5), there were plenty of highs, lows and walkers, along with the demise of two characters that wound up on TV Fanatic's list of 9 shocking deaths on The Walking Dead.

So how did the fourth season fare? Read on for our latest TV Fanatic Report Card...

Rick on the Finale

Best Episode: At times, The Walking Dead Season 4 felt a bit all over the place, but it certainly tried various things even if it didn't always succeed. That said, The Walking Dead Season 4 Episode 16 was the hour that was the end of the line for the train track walking and the arrival at Terminus. It was intense, action packed, had some character moments and an ending that made you excited to see what is coming next. And I'm just glad to see everyone mostly reunited again. Those Terminus people don't know who they are messing with!

Worst Episode: There were certainly more candidates from the second half of the season, but I still have to give it to The Walking Dead Season 4 Episode 7. "Dead Weight" felt like dead weight as the show not only paused the main story to back track, but the Governor's turn from possible redemption went right back into the exact same Governor we already knew.

It was as if nothing really changed and his "struggle" was too little too late to find interesting. And as much as I enjoy the series taking time to flesh out the characters, you could have skipped his mini backstory and not really missed anything.

Best Character: While her initial appearance to Andrea was cool, I was less than thrilled with moody Michonne as her story began in The Walking Dead Season 3. But Michonne has grown as a character and one not only worthy to be on the show but a welcome one. She's a badass samurai who gained a real personality and purpose. Cracking jokes and smiles, and revealing more of herself as a person earns this top spot of best character.

Worst Character: I can't say I've had a character I really disliked this season. But if I had to pick one, I'd say Sasha, mostly for the fact that she's pretty much just been there with not much to do. Sure, she dealt with the sickness in the beginning, and she had a mini story arc in The Walking Dead Season 4 Episode 13 that ultimately served the story of the episode. I just want to see more for her character and hope that next season can change that.

Most WTF moment: While Hershel, Lizzie and Mika's deaths were shockers, and Beth getting stolen seemed to come out of nowhere, Rick's Jaws move in The Walking Dead Season 4 finale was a real surprise. His graphic chomp-down on the biker gang leader's neck was a major WTF that allowed him to help stop the crew from killing them and showing Carl some Deliverance.

Hopes for Season 5: Hopefully, keeping the same showrunner for more than one season of The Walking Dead will help with consistency and a vision that maintains a certain path. As much as I'm hoping Terminus provides some great moments and memorable bad guys you want to love to hate, I'm eager to give the characters some focus and goal to achieve such as the journey to Washington D.C. Whether or not Eugene knows the truth doesn't matter, but getting out of Georgia and exploring that big open world could be fantastic.

And I'm looking forward to seeing more growth and backstory for the characters, especially some of the new ones. There seem like so many possibilities that for The Walking Dead Season 5 to take. Let's hope it delivers that excitement, tension and gritty horror-tale of survival and zombies that fans love when it returns next fall.

Overall Grade: B-

Your turn TV Fanatics! What would you grade The Walking Dead Season 4?

 

Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more The Walking Dead?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Glenn-and-daryl

The Walking Dead Scoop: Ready for a New Rick?

The Walking Dead Season 5 will be the best season yet of this AMC hit. According to a very reliable source.
Daryl-in-trouble

The Walking Dead First Look: Danger for Daryl!

AMC has given fans a new look at The Walking Dead Season 5. And it's a trouble one for fans of Daryl Dixon.
Vanessas-vision

Penny Dreadful Season 1 Report Card: Grade It!

What were the best and worst moments from Penny Dreadful Season 1? Check out our Report Card and give it a grade yourself.
The-walking-dead-season-5-clip

The Walking Dead Sneak Peek: Trekking to Terminus

The Walking Dead Season 5 kicks off in October. Get your first look at the premiere now.

Avatar

WHO EVER GAVE THIS AN "F" IS A COCK SUCKING BITCH
(^3^)
GOING TO SUCK THAT COCK

Avatar

Season 4 was, by far, the best season in my opinion. They're FINALLY starting to make it so the female characters aren't just there to be accessories to the male characters and do chores. I feel like this makes the writing seem much more fresh and interesting. Not to mention making the women act more self sufficient and strong means we listen to a lot less petty bickering and whining that we did in the first seasons. It was also getting pretty stale dealing with the whole governor/survival plot, so I'm glad we're getting to the "save the world" plot next season. That's going to be a heck of a lot more interesting than supply runs and farming.

Avatar
@ Crystal

The women are stupid.. its a shame the writers have to consider people like you otherwise the women would just be getting raped

Avatar

I would like to see Terminus annihilated & the crew reunited with Carol, Tyreese, Judith (restoring Carl's hope in some way) & Beth. It would make sense that the group replenish with supplies &:hopefully an armored car from Terminus as they make there way to D.C. headcount with everyone reunited (correct me if I'm wrong): 16. What if they get to D.C. & no one is left? Cool to see a zombie president!

Avatar

I would like to see Terminus annihilated & the crew reunited with Carol, Tyreese, Judith (restoring Carl's hope in some way) & Beth. It would make sense that the group replenish with supplies &:hopefully an armored car from Terminus as they make there way to D.C. headcount with everyone reunited (correct me if I'm wrong): 16. What if they get to D.C. & no one is left? Cool to see a zombie president!

Avatar

Finally someone who doesn't praise The Grove as if God himself brought it to earth. Thank you for keeping it real.

Avatar

I really loved the show. Can't wait till season 5

Avatar

I love it best all seasons can't wait to see season 5

Avatar

A little confused with a B- mark when there were so many highlights that you listed in your overall review, but ok.

Avatar

I loved season B. I love character development, story lines, phenomenal acting and dialogue in my horror/ supernatural shows. Killing zombies and running is not what does it for me, it is a character study of how people react under such extraordinary circumstances

Avatar

Love it