Joan Holloway
364 posts
Joanholloway

Posted at
Joan Holloway
364 posts
Joanholloway

Posted at
GGFAN76
1107 posts
Ggfan76

I have been stating this for a while now , but the reality is that some people will never forgive Chuck for the IP . I personally believe that if someone takes responsibility for something, seeks help, apologises and tries to make it up then they at least deserve a second chance. Some people here argue that what Chuck did was unforgiveable and are not willing to give him a chance. I , like Queen B , think he deserves a second chance. And if the character he actually did this to ( Blair) can forgive him, I find it confusing that the fans cant. I would get it if Blair hadnt just gone all in with Chuck, but she has shown time and again she forgives him, I dont get why some of you cant even give the character a chance. And because we believe he deserves a second chance , we are labelled supporters of abuse and Chuccultists. I really dont understand it at all

Posted at
4291 posts
Fackin-alpha
It's not that you believe that he deserves a second chance as a human being, it's that after that ultimate betrayal you believe he still needs to have Blair in a relationship, especially considering how horrible and controlling he's been to her several times since after the IP. A relationship usually can't survive such an event, even when one can forgive the other for such an indiscretion, but because Chuck has still been shown to feel that Blair is "his" since the IP you all must believe that she is and troll and threaten the writers until they comply with your favorite woobie.
Posted at
GGFAN76
1107 posts
Ggfan76

I know , I am not being dense buts its kind of crazy that people are harping back to the IP. It seems strange to me, its so overtly obvious that Chuck has paid for it over and over again , and he sought out help, yet its still not good enough to even warrant a chance ???

Posted at
GGFAN76
1107 posts
Ggfan76

It's not that you believe that he deserves a second chance as a human being, it's that after that ultimate betrayal you believe he still needs to have Blair in a relationship, especially considering how horrible and controlling he's been to her several times since after the IP. A relationship usually can't survive such an event, even when one can forgive the other for such an indiscretion, but because Chuck has still been shown to feel that Blair is "his" since the IP you all must believe that she is and troll and threaten the writers until they comply with your favorite woobieRead more tv spoilers at: http://www.tvfanatic.com/forum/gossip-girl/general-discussion/i-am-a-chair-fan-but-i-am-disappointed/page-6.html#ixzz1uyRn3ANi

Fackin ALpha - with all due respect , please dont tell me what I think. What you have stated is your perception of my thoughts (which is incorrect ) .Its black and white- Blair chose Chuck , he told her to walk away and make a decision he told her who she chose to love with her freedom is up to her and he left her in New York and went away to win some money - How is that controlling. Blair chased him to declare her love, Blair followed him to the casino. Chuck didnt manhandle her on the plane. He let her go to make her own decision and she chose him - how is that controlling behaviour ?

Posted at
4291 posts
Fackin-alpha
The only part I truly directed to you and only you was that you believe that B should be with C, am I wrong to think that? The rest was mostly directed to the group of Chuck fans that imposed their will any chance they got on the writers so they could get them to make Blair Chuck's again, and that's what my post was really about, pointing out why we still bring up the IP and why we think it still pertains to now and why we believe CB should've died that moment romantically. Again I never said there is a problem with Blair forgiving him, but groveling at his feet despite having him declaring war on her, humiliating her several times, and even physically abusing her(to only a certain extent) since the IP? This is something we'll always be diametrically opposed on, but im just giving you my take on why Dair and Just Blair fans can't accept CB romance still because of the IP.
Posted at
GGFAN76
1107 posts
Ggfan76

Teacakes- I know that, the writers know that, Blair knows that but apparently if someone does something wrong, they never deserve to get a chance again. I agree totally that what Chuck did was wrong , but do I think people deserve a chance after seeking help and apologising - absolutely. People make mistakes everyday in life and it would be a sad world if no one ever got a second chance

Posted at
GGFAN76
1107 posts
Ggfan76

@FA- If you look on twitter today and over the last two weeks there has been a lot of not so nice comments to the writers from Dair fans , and prior to that Chair fans so fault in regards to what people are saying to the writers lie on both sides. If Dair fans cant accept the IP , that is their perrogative , I find it sad because Blair has accepted it and moved on - she's the one in the middle of all of this, she can forgive Chuck , so I guess thats all that matters to me as a Dair fan

Posted at
GGFAN76
1107 posts
Ggfan76

Woah that meant to be Chair fan ...oops

Posted at

Post a Reply

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register.

Guest posting is disabled in this forum. If you want to post, please Sign In or Register.