Wow! I am shocked at this review and the comments. Idol talks about being true to one's self and do your best. Joshua out sang EVERYONE hands down. This might not be the best outlet for his talent but he was phenomenal! None of the girls were impressive and most were pitchy and over-dramatic... Hollie was terrible and very pitchy. But after Josh, I cant blame her. Shannon was pitchy too. A lot of the problems were attributed to song choice. Hopefully, they wont eliminate anyone tonight and they will all get a chance to redeem themselves next week!