Mary Kate and Ashley Olsen? Maybe. Oprah and Gayle? We could see that.
But with the Internet spitting out a number of options for True Detective Season 2, Jimmy Kimmel and Seth Rogen made their pitch for the lead roles last night... and they were pretty convincing!
In the following skit, the host and the actor team up as versions of Rust and Marty, driving around town, crushing beer cans and quoting many famous songs in the process.
Seriously, who would NOT watch True Detective Season 2 with this pair at the forefront?!?
Here are a few more suggestions, courtesy of Twitter: