TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

The Firm Review: The Lying Game

by at . Comments

"Chapter Three" continued in the same vein as the two-hour series premiere, starting off with some high tension, as Mitch McDeere was chased during the present time before jumping backwards in time to focus on Mitch, his clients and his first real steps as a part of the (unbeknownst to him) shady firm, Kinross & Clark.

Sure, the episode threw a lot at the viewer in terms of story, but I think it worked for the better. Giving Mitch multiple clients is a fresh step in terms of the normal one and done plot most law procedurals. In a way, The Firm follows a similar linear path for its particular cases of the week, but by weaving in and out other storylines, it didn't feel completely like a stand alone episode.

It's ambitious, and the writers have to make sure not to throw out so many different directions that some get lost in the wind, but it works in keeping a pace that feels like the show is moving forward.

There is a sense that the entire season, much like a book or movie, will have a complete story to tell amongst all the little ones that are scattered throughout. At least I hope that's how it all comes to fruition.

McDeere Brothers

It's obvious that Mitch is resolute and dedicated to the law, and while that works for him as the hero of the show, it also serves as a certain flaw to his character. It is, of course, a good flaw that causes his own inner conflict to ring out.

In defending Calvin Parker, Mitch knew his client was innocent and was willing to set the man free even with the possibility of having the murder finger pointed at his other client, Ryan. That said, Mitch knew where Amy's body was located but refused to Calvin. His idea that the "law is the law" brings forth many rules and situations that can make being a lawyer difficult, especially when he realized that Calvin did actually kill people. Having a conscience is tough.

But, in the end, despite his mistake, Mitch remained focused on defending his clients and bringing them justice. It all worked out for him.

And I love that he was proactive throughout the episode, even bringing his work home with him. It never seems like he stops to catch a breath, but at the same time he is clearly passionate about his work. There is a dedication and like-ability that Josh Lucas pulls out of the character, making me want to watch him. A strong lead like Lucas will certainly help keep the show on its feet.

I'm also glad that the big conspiracy case surrounding Sara Holt received a little attention but for now, it doesn't seem anything out of the ordinary besides a murder case.

As for Martin and his connection, I have a feeling that his company will play an important role. And what is with all that sniffing? I know they joked about cocaine and a cold, but could he be infected with a virus? Is his company creating some drug that is deadly? I know my theory could be a stretch since we don't really have any information, but I could definitely see a pharmaceutical company as the big bad guy of the season.

For all of the fast pacing and suspense involved, I was a little disappointed at how Ryan and Calvin's case was quickly wrapped up at the end. I know it served to close that case of the week, but I was almost hoping that the series would extend one of them into the next episode. Calvin was creepy enough and the thought that Mitch let a killer go could have played a particular psychological game with him for at least a few more episodes.

I also don't understand how Claire is allowed to be in Abby's class. Isn't that not permitted? I guess it gives them mother/daughter screen time, but it felt like it took away from the interesting legal drama. Even when Abby was talking to Tammy about the cheating situation, I kept thinking that, compared to what Mitch was dealing with, it felt slow and stuck in purely to incorporate a sense of character development. Except it wasn't that interesting and I just wanted to get back to Mitch.

While I recognize that The Firm isn't filled with crazy jaw dropping twists (at least for now) it does provide a sense of intensity and suspense when it comes to each particular case. Again, nothing feels overly new or groundbreaking, but the drama does manage to keep a strong formula in place, delivering gripping episodes centered around a main character worth watching.

Review

Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.5 / 5.0 (34 Votes)

Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Avatar

Is The Firm getting cancelled? I used to follow reviews until they stopped here, I knew something was wrong then. Especially now it seems they are moving The Firm to Saturdays. Isn't that what they did for Prime Suspect and Chase? I think people got fed up of the toss between the past and the future (the few seconds of the future). You have to admit that the storyline flowed, despite the back and forth. They have attractive actors and well the writing is decent, so what isn't clicking for this one? I had only hoped it would have lasted for a full two season run, so we could at least get to learn each character and give closure to the story line.

Avatar

Coming out of witness protection, they had an opportunity to give Abby a little more interesting career. For god sake its DC, make her a congressional aid or something more interesting than an elementary school teacher.

Fortyseven

I agree with the review. On the one hand, if the wife and daughter on on the show, they should have scenes but on the other hand, they need to be interesting. At least the episode wasn't dragged down by them. Mind you they did have Abby help Mitch inadvertently much like how Castle's daughter and mother help him by triggering a line of thought. It's fine as long as it isn't overused. The group discussions are kinda weird.

Avatar

What a waste of money.

Avatar

"The whole Abby and daughter's school life story line is not working. The story line is wasted time. I agree Ryan and Calvin's could have been wrapped up better. It should have been given more time." --------------------------
My thoughts exactly. I do like how they go back and forth in time. They show a little more into the future. Very well done overall so far.

Avatar

I wanted to know if The Firm was worth watching. This article came up as a Google result for "The Firm pilot review", but I had to shut it off because it's infested with spoilers.

Avatar

I don't mind seeing Mitch bring his work home, but I am not into the group sessions solving the mysteries, too tacky. How does Tammy go from vacuuming the carpet to becoming a Sherlock Holmes? Don't get me wrong, I believe her character can be strong(see Donna in Suits). Lawyers argue the law, teachers teach, and secretaries manage the office. How does Ray suddenly become an investigator? If you are going to make Ray an investigator, I would give him a quirky mentor, so we know where he is learning how to investigate. Abby never got involved with Mitch's cases unless it directly involved her, it should stay that way. In order to allow Mitch to discuss the cases, I would give him a partner in his office. The whole Abby and daughter's school life story line is not working. The story line is wasted time. I agree Ryan and Calvin's could have been wrapped up better. It should have been given more time.

The Firm Season 1 Episode 3 Quotes

Boundaries? That's not a word you use in a law firm. That's a word you use in couples therapy.

Andrew

I'm not letting some jaded public defender screw this up.

Mitch