Alcatraz Review: All In The Family

by at . Comments

Alcatraz continued to wade knee deep in mystery mystery, and more mystery this week.

"Guy Hastings" took a varied approach to the returnee inmates from the prison by actually back one of the disappeared guards.

Thankfully, the flashbacks incorporated a sense of who Guy Hastings was as a person (a good guy following the rules of the system), while also allowing some insight into Rebecca Madsen's familial connections to the infamous jail.

Not only was her grandfather a prisoner there, but he had a brother who happened to be a guard. Oh yes, Ray Archer is Rebecca's great uncle.

Rebecca and Uncle

Perhaps what's more interesting is that Ray was originally approached by Emerson Hauser 16 years earlier to help him. Of course, that means he's known that Tommy Madsen has been back all this time. But does he know why?

Either way, there's a definite animosity between the two brothers. Time has not been good for their relationship. But, again... why?

I'm glad that Guy took a few moments to begin elaborating on what happened to him and shed a shimmer of light on the lies that he and fellow guards had been told. Yet, what was his statement about it suddenly not being 1963 anymore? Did he jump forward in time?

My questioning quandary with all of the returnees is to why they come back disgruntled, violent and on a mission from a mysterious "they," even though they don't have any clue as to the reason themselves.

I just don't understand what Guy's motives for hunting down Tommy were, let alone hurting his fellow guard for the sake of his mission. Guy seemed like a good natured person, evidenced in the flashbacks with his wife and daughter, as well as seeing his grown up daughter in the present time.

Clearly, the reappearing members of Alcatraz aren't robotic and emotionless Terminators, so why would Guy choose to hurt people? Was it because he felt like he was trying to capture a convicted felon, something a respectable guard would do?

It's as if these people appear and then go on these missions without question, but I've never gotten the sense that the reason they do them is because their lives are threatened, they're being blackmailed, they're promised something in return, etc. Rather, they seem lost and then when Emerson finally captures them, they go "oh, well, you got me, but I can't answer any of your questions because I have zero clue."

Wow. Whoever, whatever or whenever, is pulling the strings, they sure know how to control and delegate their subjects.

At least Guy's reasons for using Ray made perfect sense and he didn't feel as thrown into the weekly mix as Cal Sweeney had in the last episode. The fact that there was a personal connection allowed for the story to provide greater stakes and focus on the main characters, rather than just the new character of the week.

Although, as a main character, Rebecca really needs to work on not getting captured so often. Sure, she manages to escape in the long run, but she shouldn't be making herself a hostage or easy shooting target every time. She needs to not burst onto every scene like she has it under control, when she actually has zero control.

I still can't help but love every line that comes out of Jorge Garica's mouth, from his questions about the "bat phone" to realizing all his work on Alcatraz and knowing most of it is wrong makes him something of a fraud. His humor, curiosity, knowledge and relate-ability in questioning everything that takes place makes for a fantastic character and it seems safe to say he will continue to be enjoyable every week.

But what is happening in these episodes through dialogue? Is there a need for Rebecca and Emerson to restate the facts? The audience doesn't have to be spoon fed the plot direction. The worst was when one scientist questioned the relation of the keys, the jump and Tommy Madsen.

Really? Have you not been paying attention? Of course, they are all related. What a ridiculous question. Someone should fire him for sleeping on the job.

It's easy to see all of the mysterious happenings and people are connected to each other.

So, Alcatraz continued to propel itself forward here, surrounded by deep mysteries and various questions that build upon one another (although it gives me a sneaking Lost feeling.) Which makes me certainly intrigued, and I know that not everything should be answered quickly and early, that would defeat the show entirely.

Still, at some point, some type of understanding or revelation as to why for any number of questions surrounding Alcatraz prison need to emerge. The story needs to find itself moving forward and coinciding with the fascinating questions and secrets. I'm ready to see the characters journey toward discovery at the same time they round up the weekly bad guys.

Why is Tommy Madsen important? What does Emerson want with him? Why are people returning? Who is "they?" What do they want? Why did they disappear? Sound off with your own questions, comments, and theories below.

Review

Editor Rating: 3.8 / 5.0
  • 3.8 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.7 / 5.0 (52 Votes)

Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Alcatraz?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Julia-takes-the-lead

Under the Dome Review: What's 1821?

Power struggles ensue all around Chester's Mill on Under the Dome. Lives will be put on the line.
Facing-off-against-kate

Teen Wolf Review: No One Else Dies

Scott decides to get tough on Teen Wolf after rescuing his Beta by declaring he won't sit back and watch more deaths. Find out what else went down in the review!
Tamra-and-vicki

The Real Housewives of Orange County Review: Pity Party, Table For One

Heather and Tamra consider making peace with Shannon on The Real Housewives of Orange County. See what went down in our TV Fanatic review!
Winding-down

Murder in the First Review: And the Verdict Is...

On Murder in the First, the trial of Erich Blunt reaches its conclusion. But what is the verdict? Find out when you read the review.

Avatar

God I wish they'd hire someone over the age of 17 to write these reviews. All due respect, this show sucks. These shows are like an old pontiac with a new paint job. Sure it looks good, but the piont is covering rust, bondo and at least two accidents. There is no mystery except how this show got placed on the air with the crap dialog, writing and plotting. Seriously, how many family ties does this cop chick need at the "rock?" The acting is good - they at least got that right and hired good talent, but the writers ad producers blow. No amount of good acting can cover the stink of the writing. The bar is so low for what mysterious that people jump over something an inch high and think they're ready for the olympics..

Ronald-simkins

I am so glad that "Hoyt" didn't turn out to be evil. This was actually an excellent episode because we don't really know if Tommy is "bad" and what his real relationship with Ray is.

Avatar

Sean I agree that Rebecca needs to captured less. I like this show. We can't have all the answers at once, but we did get more this week about Rebecca's family connection. Obviously Sam Neill's character, Emerson, knows more then he is telling. The female, Lucy, who is on a respiratory at the moment, was she not the MD back in 1963. So is she friend of Emerson or actually foe. Does she not remember her experiment back in 1963, which kept her from aging also? They still have to explain that. I love Jorge's, Doc Soto character as well. I sticking with this show, I am intrigued.

Avatar

I'm still likeing it...the whole nut shell shouldn't be revealed yet, then where would the show go? But my husband is getting confused with it and wanting more answers each week then what we have been getting...he feels it needs to move a little faster forward as well...sigh...well we'll see! Still Love Hugo!!! lol

Fortyseven

Ugh! I agree. I can't decide if it's the writing or the plotting that's worse. Rebecah's been captured 2? 3? times! She should be reviewed or whatever. The repetition was killing me. I'll give it 2 or 3 more episodes then I'm bailing.