One Tree Hill Review: Was Lucas Scott Here? Comments (Page 3)
64 Comments
sara
February 23rd, 2012 11:18 AM
Only mark and the cast of one tree hill can pull of am episode like this I was so relieved when the cop showed up only to find out that he s not really their to help. Not much happened but it was a pretty good episode they pretty much all are ....
nutmeg024 Rank: Guest Star
February 23rd, 2012 11:13 AM
Now for nathan .... omfg - giirls, how hot was he the entire episode. "You may take my world,you may take my life, but u will never have my fear...." ddddaaaaammmmmnnnnn. From the moment we knew he was about to esccape to the moment the cop hit him upside the head my heart was beating soooo fast and hard I thought it was gonna jump out of my chest. Very exhillerating!!!
I just saw someone elses post and I also have thought since the kid second episode that clay and quinn woukd adopt him.
Also - I really really really really hope the sheet scene with hayley in the morgue is a nightmare of hayleys. If not, I have wasted 9 years watching this just to be let down - DO NOT KILL NATHAN. ....... there will be consequences,lol.
nutmeg024 Rank: Guest Star
February 23rd, 2012 11:04 AM
For some reason I am really intrigued by dans story line. I can't wait to see him be the one to bring nathan home. I don't think anyone should forgive him for what he's done but I don't think he should be punished forever either.
Logan being clays child? I'm not sure, I definately think there's a connection betweenthe two, but I think that they would have found clay after he left to return his child. Also wouldn't sarah (the ghost one he talked to at the beach house) have told him he has a kid. I dunno about all that.
Cont....
MET
February 23rd, 2012 11:01 AM
I don't think Logan is Clay's kid, but I think they will adopt him.
nutmeg024 Rank: Guest Star
February 23rd, 2012 10:52 AM
I was dissaapointed with this episode for the mere fact that they built up his return sooo much and said that he returned to help hayley find nathan, and then that was all we got. My heart swelled when they were looking for him at the gateway, I was soo happy. Then when he called her hales, aaaawwwww - it brought me back. I also agree that someone besides quinn hould have went with her, however, someone asked why isn't brook there for her and whatnot, u have to remember that they are all young adults with kids jobs and responsibiliities - they do not have free time to be with eachother all day like they did in hs. Quinn prob went with her cause she's her sister and no one else is available. Cont.....
Christina Tran Rank: Staff Member
February 23rd, 2012 10:19 AM
Great review, Dan. I loved what you said about Luke, and I still miss CMM and especially Brucas so much. It's too bad that Peyton and Sawyer couldn't make an appearance, but I'm glad that they were mentioned.
Honestly, this episode made me just want to rewatch OTH from the beginning... back in the best of times!
Biancaa
February 23rd, 2012 9:41 AM
Dan was boring.
Julian was boring.
Felt bad for Brooke but was so focused on Nathan that her storyline just seemed irrelevant, she should've went to the airport with Haley, NOT QUINN.
Quinn's always boring.
Clay is a cutie, I feel bad for him but just want him to get better so he can help find Nathan cause thats clearly what he wants to do. Then he can adopt Logan, who I for one think is his and Sara's kid. Which would be AWESOME. Cause he's the cutest kid ever!
Loved the Chase and Chuck think. Can't wait to see Chase beat the shit out of Chuck's asshole of a dad!
All in all, I love this show. I love Nathan Scott and I love James Lafferty for tugging on my heart strings with this storyline. Him being all badass and brave shows me exactly why he was chosen to play Nathan and why I love this show.
Biancaa
February 23rd, 2012 9:40 AM
I love that Lucas came just to take the kids. He's being there for Nathan's family when Nathan can't. Haley is having a tough enough time having to worry about Nathan. Oh man that cop. When he went to Haley's house I knew there was something shady about him. But then when Nathan escape I was like YES! Oh man, he's so sexy (just a sidenote) Then the cop was there and I forgot about how uneasy I felt about him, especially when he gave him the gun. I just wanted to jump through the TV and punch him in the face repeatedly. But that may have been an extreme. I keep saying it's not Nathan under the sheet, but I'm still scared. What would stop them? It's the final season. Like Mark Schwahnn would definitely want to end it with a bang, and what better way than causing so much shock? Also, it was really sweet of Lucas to just come to pick up the kids, plane tickets are expensive!
Susan
February 23rd, 2012 9:22 AM
I was so happy to see Lucas, but really sad that it was for such a short time I really thought they would of had him stay to help found Nathan, cause that is what the old Lucas would of done he would of never walked away while Haley was so up set and his brother missing that would of never happened
Aya M
February 23rd, 2012 8:23 AM
It was SO great to see Lucas again, even for a short period of time. I definitely agree with the reviewer. It was refreshing, and it felt right. His presence/character has definitely been missed on so many levels.
I know it was short, but regardless of how long his appearance was or what he did, I don't think any of us would have been completely happy for anything less than him staying for the rest of the season. So, it was short and sweet, and I'll take it! I appreciate CMM returning for the happiness of his fans.
As soon as the cop showed up at Hailey's door, I knew he was up to something shady. I agree with the commenter below who said this has revenge for Dan written all over it. I sure hope so, cause that definitely makes more sense.
Looking forward to Deb's return! Seriously, between Deb and Dan, Nathan should be back in no time.
tinker
February 23rd, 2012 8:12 AM
Am I'm the only person that finds it crazy that in tree hill, u can murder someone, lie about it, kidnap, etc and only serve like 5 years in jail. I'm about to move there.
It reminds me of the movie "Hostel". Dmitri keeps telling nathan he is going to die...also think chase is going to beat the crap out of skolnicks dad..that's prob why they show him in cop car earlier.
Ashleymellir
February 23rd, 2012 7:09 AM
I am still on the fence about this ep, as far as the person under the blanket goes, I think it will end up being just a dream.
Katarina
February 23rd, 2012 6:00 AM
You guys are making awesome points! I agree! I mean it just doesnt make sence that Brook and others arnt there for haley. To be honest Clay is starting to frustrate me, its like "dude, a dead guy gave you his kidney, your alive, you have an awesome girl etc" stop being a sooki lala, and for god sake listen to the doctor and stop trying to be a tough guy to cool for therapy.
czarina
February 23rd, 2012 5:49 AM
it's just not right that Lucas only came and went! I love the airport episode, i actually had Haley and Lucas great friendship flashbacks, love that he came to help Haley with the kids.. But for him to not have any encounter with the other characters??? Sad!! All those minutes wasted on Dan watching and watching the video and Clay's session could have been used for more Lucas airtime! And amidst all this, where are the other FRIENDS?? Seriously, Brooke is only Haley's girlfriend and they don't make her be with her? And rather have her waste time on that attacker! That storyline better be relevant!!!
PinkPig
February 23rd, 2012 5:44 AM
sorry its Chase that's goibg to do something to Chucks dad not Clay
PinkPig
February 23rd, 2012 5:40 AM
Lucas coming back...great to see, waste of time.
Nathan isn't under the sheet but didnt they say a MAJOR character wouldnt see the finale.
Chuck's dad is an ASS. And Clay will get in trouble for doing something to him....which means NO AIRFORCE.
Clay so is Logans dad, or by the end will want to be. Did you see his face when the doc asked how he would feel if Quinn got preggers.
Brooke stood up for herself and Q. How creepy was Xavier face in Karen's Cafe.
COP, DRUG DEALER, EUROPEAN MOBSTER IN ON A KIDNAPPING OF NATHAN HAS REVENGE FOR DAN WRITTEN ALL OVER IT!!!!
Katarina
February 23rd, 2012 5:32 AM
@GeekyDiorGirl - I totally agree with you. Its a shame isnt it.
GeekyDiorGirl Rank: Extra
February 23rd, 2012 4:52 AM
The fact that Halle is going thru this and Skills, Mouth, Lucas, and Peyton are MIA shows just how out of touch with the show these new writers are. Even Brooke is MIA ans you would expect her to be by Halle's side like 24/7. These characters were so close and it rings so false that they all are like "Nathan will come home. Ok talk to u later."
Katarina
February 23rd, 2012 4:09 AM
Hey Guys!! I have gotten some info for us about the next 2 episodes. Definitely applying for a job at TV-Fanatic LOL's.
Anyway, we can breath as it is NOT Nathan under the sheet. Here are the key points of what will happen.
Episode 8, A Rush of Blood to the Head
• Haley receives news of a possible tragedy
• Dan’s search for Nathan leads him back to his dark past
• Clay has a breakthrough in his treatment
• Brooke and Julian deal with Xavier
• Chase’s concern for Chuck pushes him to his limits
• BARBARA ALYN WOODS GUEST STAR
Episode 9, Every Breath Is A Bomb
• HALEY PARTNERS WITH DAN IN HIS SEARCH FOR NATHAN’S WHEREABOUTS
• Brooke and Julian take new measures to protect their family
• Skills helps Mouth get to a turning point
• Chase faces consequences for defending Chuck
• Clay reaches a new understanding with Logan
Katarina
February 23rd, 2012 3:36 AM
a) I THINK IT MIGHT BE 'DAN' UNDER THE SHEET OR SOMEONE ELSE, BUT DEFINATELY NOT NATHAN. I mean that would just be redicolous on the writers part. After 7 years of being faithfull fans to our core/main characters, if Mark Schwan killed one of the 2 brothers/basketball, which is what the show is about, would make fans who carried this show very very very dissapointed.
b) I HOPE NATHAN WON'T BE IN THIS SITUATION FOR THE REST OF THE FINAL SEASON.
c) YES, VERY DISSAPOINTED THAT LUCAS CAME & WENT.
d) I THINK CHASE WILL BEAT UP CHUK'S DAD, & THAT WILL BE THE REASON HE ENDS UP ARRESTED & IN THE COP CAR, AS SHOWN IN THE SEASON 9 PROMO
e) THE COP SUCKS, DODGY CRAP, I HATE THAT. WANT DAN TO HURRY UP & FIND NATHAN.
Erika
February 23rd, 2012 3:09 AM
If it is Brooke under the sheet then idk what i will do. Also i dont think its Nathan because i hear the last episode will have Nathan narrating and i doubt they would do that if they were going to kill him off. Also I still think it was stupid to continue the show without Chad and to only have him sitting in an airport talking to Hailey as his final farewell was not the proper ending I wanted!!!!!! I hope he comes back for the Last episode as a surprise you cannot end the show without him.
~Katrina~ Rank: Regular Character
February 23rd, 2012 2:47 AM
Oh no no no!
If its Brooke or Nathan under that sheet, I will be very pissed!
Kat
February 23rd, 2012 2:00 AM
I'm wondering if the person under the sheet next week is Brooke. Just don't think it's Nathan. With bad guy standing outside her place watching her, I'm thinking that could definitely give us a shock. And it would break hearts
julia
February 23rd, 2012 1:58 AM
I have this horrid feeling it's going to be Brooke under that sheet!
Nate: Oh wait, you've already been kidnapped. Jamie: So have you.
February 23rd, 2012 11:18 AM
Only mark and the cast of one tree hill can pull of am episode like this I was so relieved when the cop showed up only to find out that he s not really their to help. Not much happened but it was a pretty good episode they pretty much all are ....
Rank: Guest Star
February 23rd, 2012 11:13 AM
Now for nathan .... omfg - giirls, how hot was he the entire episode. "You may take my world,you may take my life, but u will never have my fear...." ddddaaaaammmmmnnnnn. From the moment we knew he was about to esccape to the moment the cop hit him upside the head my heart was beating soooo fast and hard I thought it was gonna jump out of my chest. Very exhillerating!!!
I just saw someone elses post and I also have thought since the kid second episode that clay and quinn woukd adopt him.
Also - I really really really really hope the sheet scene with hayley in the morgue is a nightmare of hayleys. If not, I have wasted 9 years watching this just to be let down - DO NOT KILL NATHAN. ....... there will be consequences,lol.
Rank: Guest Star
February 23rd, 2012 11:04 AM
For some reason I am really intrigued by dans story line. I can't wait to see him be the one to bring nathan home. I don't think anyone should forgive him for what he's done but I don't think he should be punished forever either.
Logan being clays child? I'm not sure, I definately think there's a connection betweenthe two, but I think that they would have found clay after he left to return his child. Also wouldn't sarah (the ghost one he talked to at the beach house) have told him he has a kid. I dunno about all that.
Cont....
February 23rd, 2012 11:01 AM
I don't think Logan is Clay's kid, but I think they will adopt him.
Rank: Guest Star
February 23rd, 2012 10:52 AM
I was dissaapointed with this episode for the mere fact that they built up his return sooo much and said that he returned to help hayley find nathan, and then that was all we got. My heart swelled when they were looking for him at the gateway, I was soo happy. Then when he called her hales, aaaawwwww - it brought me back. I also agree that someone besides quinn hould have went with her, however, someone asked why isn't brook there for her and whatnot, u have to remember that they are all young adults with kids jobs and responsibiliities - they do not have free time to be with eachother all day like they did in hs. Quinn prob went with her cause she's her sister and no one else is available. Cont.....
Rank: Staff Member
February 23rd, 2012 10:19 AM
Great review, Dan. I loved what you said about Luke, and I still miss CMM and especially Brucas so much. It's too bad that Peyton and Sawyer couldn't make an appearance, but I'm glad that they were mentioned.
Honestly, this episode made me just want to rewatch OTH from the beginning... back in the best of times!
February 23rd, 2012 9:41 AM
Dan was boring.
Julian was boring.
Felt bad for Brooke but was so focused on Nathan that her storyline just seemed irrelevant, she should've went to the airport with Haley, NOT QUINN.
Quinn's always boring.
Clay is a cutie, I feel bad for him but just want him to get better so he can help find Nathan cause thats clearly what he wants to do. Then he can adopt Logan, who I for one think is his and Sara's kid. Which would be AWESOME. Cause he's the cutest kid ever!
Loved the Chase and Chuck think. Can't wait to see Chase beat the shit out of Chuck's asshole of a dad!
All in all, I love this show. I love Nathan Scott and I love James Lafferty for tugging on my heart strings with this storyline. Him being all badass and brave shows me exactly why he was chosen to play Nathan and why I love this show.
February 23rd, 2012 9:40 AM
I love that Lucas came just to take the kids. He's being there for Nathan's family when Nathan can't. Haley is having a tough enough time having to worry about Nathan. Oh man that cop. When he went to Haley's house I knew there was something shady about him. But then when Nathan escape I was like YES! Oh man, he's so sexy (just a sidenote) Then the cop was there and I forgot about how uneasy I felt about him, especially when he gave him the gun. I just wanted to jump through the TV and punch him in the face repeatedly. But that may have been an extreme. I keep saying it's not Nathan under the sheet, but I'm still scared. What would stop them? It's the final season. Like Mark Schwahnn would definitely want to end it with a bang, and what better way than causing so much shock? Also, it was really sweet of Lucas to just come to pick up the kids, plane tickets are expensive!
February 23rd, 2012 9:22 AM
I was so happy to see Lucas, but really sad that it was for such a short time I really thought they would of had him stay to help found Nathan, cause that is what the old Lucas would of done he would of never walked away while Haley was so up set and his brother missing that would of never happened
February 23rd, 2012 8:23 AM
It was SO great to see Lucas again, even for a short period of time. I definitely agree with the reviewer. It was refreshing, and it felt right. His presence/character has definitely been missed on so many levels.
I know it was short, but regardless of how long his appearance was or what he did, I don't think any of us would have been completely happy for anything less than him staying for the rest of the season. So, it was short and sweet, and I'll take it! I appreciate CMM returning for the happiness of his fans.
As soon as the cop showed up at Hailey's door, I knew he was up to something shady. I agree with the commenter below who said this has revenge for Dan written all over it. I sure hope so, cause that definitely makes more sense.
Looking forward to Deb's return! Seriously, between Deb and Dan, Nathan should be back in no time.
February 23rd, 2012 8:12 AM
Am I'm the only person that finds it crazy that in tree hill, u can murder someone, lie about it, kidnap, etc and only serve like 5 years in jail. I'm about to move there.
Rank: New User
February 23rd, 2012 7:37 AM
It reminds me of the movie "Hostel". Dmitri keeps telling nathan he is going to die...also think chase is going to beat the crap out of skolnicks dad..that's prob why they show him in cop car earlier.
February 23rd, 2012 7:09 AM
I am still on the fence about this ep, as far as the person under the blanket goes, I think it will end up being just a dream.
February 23rd, 2012 6:00 AM
You guys are making awesome points! I agree! I mean it just doesnt make sence that Brook and others arnt there for haley. To be honest Clay is starting to frustrate me, its like "dude, a dead guy gave you his kidney, your alive, you have an awesome girl etc" stop being a sooki lala, and for god sake listen to the doctor and stop trying to be a tough guy to cool for therapy.
February 23rd, 2012 5:49 AM
it's just not right that Lucas only came and went! I love the airport episode, i actually had Haley and Lucas great friendship flashbacks, love that he came to help Haley with the kids.. But for him to not have any encounter with the other characters??? Sad!! All those minutes wasted on Dan watching and watching the video and Clay's session could have been used for more Lucas airtime! And amidst all this, where are the other FRIENDS?? Seriously, Brooke is only Haley's girlfriend and they don't make her be with her? And rather have her waste time on that attacker! That storyline better be relevant!!!
February 23rd, 2012 5:44 AM
sorry its Chase that's goibg to do something to Chucks dad not Clay
February 23rd, 2012 5:40 AM
Lucas coming back...great to see, waste of time.
Nathan isn't under the sheet but didnt they say a MAJOR character wouldnt see the finale.
Chuck's dad is an ASS. And Clay will get in trouble for doing something to him....which means NO AIRFORCE.
Clay so is Logans dad, or by the end will want to be. Did you see his face when the doc asked how he would feel if Quinn got preggers.
Brooke stood up for herself and Q. How creepy was Xavier face in Karen's Cafe.
COP, DRUG DEALER, EUROPEAN MOBSTER IN ON A KIDNAPPING OF NATHAN HAS REVENGE FOR DAN WRITTEN ALL OVER IT!!!!
February 23rd, 2012 5:32 AM
@GeekyDiorGirl - I totally agree with you. Its a shame isnt it.
Rank: Extra
February 23rd, 2012 4:52 AM
The fact that Halle is going thru this and Skills, Mouth, Lucas, and Peyton are MIA shows just how out of touch with the show these new writers are. Even Brooke is MIA ans you would expect her to be by Halle's side like 24/7. These characters were so close and it rings so false that they all are like "Nathan will come home. Ok talk to u later."
February 23rd, 2012 4:09 AM
Hey Guys!! I have gotten some info for us about the next 2 episodes. Definitely applying for a job at TV-Fanatic LOL's.
Anyway, we can breath as it is NOT Nathan under the sheet. Here are the key points of what will happen.
Episode 8, A Rush of Blood to the Head
• Haley receives news of a possible tragedy
• Dan’s search for Nathan leads him back to his dark past
• Clay has a breakthrough in his treatment
• Brooke and Julian deal with Xavier
• Chase’s concern for Chuck pushes him to his limits
• BARBARA ALYN WOODS GUEST STAR
Episode 9, Every Breath Is A Bomb
• HALEY PARTNERS WITH DAN IN HIS SEARCH FOR NATHAN’S WHEREABOUTS
• Brooke and Julian take new measures to protect their family
• Skills helps Mouth get to a turning point
• Chase faces consequences for defending Chuck
• Clay reaches a new understanding with Logan
February 23rd, 2012 3:36 AM
a) I THINK IT MIGHT BE 'DAN' UNDER THE SHEET OR SOMEONE ELSE, BUT DEFINATELY NOT NATHAN. I mean that would just be redicolous on the writers part. After 7 years of being faithfull fans to our core/main characters, if Mark Schwan killed one of the 2 brothers/basketball, which is what the show is about, would make fans who carried this show very very very dissapointed.
b) I HOPE NATHAN WON'T BE IN THIS SITUATION FOR THE REST OF THE FINAL SEASON.
c) YES, VERY DISSAPOINTED THAT LUCAS CAME & WENT.
d) I THINK CHASE WILL BEAT UP CHUK'S DAD, & THAT WILL BE THE REASON HE ENDS UP ARRESTED & IN THE COP CAR, AS SHOWN IN THE SEASON 9 PROMO
e) THE COP SUCKS, DODGY CRAP, I HATE THAT. WANT DAN TO HURRY UP & FIND NATHAN.
February 23rd, 2012 3:09 AM
If it is Brooke under the sheet then idk what i will do. Also i dont think its Nathan because i hear the last episode will have Nathan narrating and i doubt they would do that if they were going to kill him off. Also I still think it was stupid to continue the show without Chad and to only have him sitting in an airport talking to Hailey as his final farewell was not the proper ending I wanted!!!!!! I hope he comes back for the Last episode as a surprise you cannot end the show without him.
Rank: Regular Character
February 23rd, 2012 2:47 AM
Oh no no no!
If its Brooke or Nathan under that sheet, I will be very pissed!
February 23rd, 2012 2:00 AM
I'm wondering if the person under the sheet next week is Brooke. Just don't think it's Nathan. With bad guy standing outside her place watching her, I'm thinking that could definitely give us a shock. And it would break hearts
February 23rd, 2012 1:58 AM
I have this horrid feeling it's going to be Brooke under that sheet!