One Tree Hill Review: Was Lucas Scott Here? Comments (Page 4)
64 Comments
shawnhunter
February 23rd, 2012 1:16 AM
what a complete waste of Lucas. Seeing him show up at the airport was the highlight of the season, but after the first original joy of seeing his face, he did nothing. he contributed to one of the most boring episodes of One Tree Hill history. 45 minutes of Haley, Lucas, Jamie, and Quinn saying "everything will be OK" and "Nathan will come home" over and over to each other. Add to that the Nathan video played 4 times, and we have a 4 minute episode turned into 40. And the couples list is falling apart. Julian has been awful for weeks now, and his terrible acting is really starting to shine through. One last bit, to have Lucas come back and not get an interaction between him and Brooke is a travesty.
Jarrod Mitchell Rank: Leading Character
February 23rd, 2012 1:07 AM
I thought it was rather disappointing. I'm actually appalled. I don't mean to sound ungrateful, because I'm glad Lucas returned, but I found the return quite wasteful. I'm not gonna complain about how cutting Lucas and Peyton to begin with was a mistake, because well, everybody knows that, but this was just awful. I didn't really wanna tune in because Peyton was not in it, but I liked Lucas and I thought he was worth it. I've missed seeing him and Haley, but most of all, I've missed seeing him and Nathan. Even a scene with Dan would have been great. But they've completely wasted such great talent and homage to the TWO characters in which the show was meant to centre around - Lucas and Nathan as brothers. I know that all of this may seem irrelevant, but it's honestly just offensive to fans that they wasted a chance like this. Considering Chad has admitted to wanting to come back, they could have given up a 5 episode arc or something to fill in for the episodes Nathan won't be in.
Andrea
February 23rd, 2012 12:49 AM
I thought the episode was really good! It didn't really pick up until more than half way through but when it did it got really intense!!
Lucas clearly hasn't been there for Haley, Brooke, or the rest of Tree Hill through a LOT of stuff over the past couple of seasons, so I didn't expect him to come back and socialize with everyone. I agree that it felt real, and his interactions with Haley have always made for one of my favourite relationships, so I enjoyed his appearance.
I usually could care less about Clay but I actually kind of like his storyline this season, especially his interactions with Logan.
I knew the cop was bad as soon as he showed up there, it just seemed like Nathan was so close and it couldn't be that simple! It seems like the dead body is going to turn up over the next couple of episodes so my guess is the storyline will be at least partially wrapped up soon enough!
~Katrina~ Rank: Regular Character
February 23rd, 2012 12:47 AM
Nate: Oh wait, you've already been kidnapped. Jamie: So have you.
February 23rd, 2012 1:16 AM
what a complete waste of Lucas. Seeing him show up at the airport was the highlight of the season, but after the first original joy of seeing his face, he did nothing. he contributed to one of the most boring episodes of One Tree Hill history. 45 minutes of Haley, Lucas, Jamie, and Quinn saying "everything will be OK" and "Nathan will come home" over and over to each other. Add to that the Nathan video played 4 times, and we have a 4 minute episode turned into 40. And the couples list is falling apart. Julian has been awful for weeks now, and his terrible acting is really starting to shine through. One last bit, to have Lucas come back and not get an interaction between him and Brooke is a travesty.
Rank: Leading Character
February 23rd, 2012 1:07 AM
I thought it was rather disappointing. I'm actually appalled. I don't mean to sound ungrateful, because I'm glad Lucas returned, but I found the return quite wasteful. I'm not gonna complain about how cutting Lucas and Peyton to begin with was a mistake, because well, everybody knows that, but this was just awful. I didn't really wanna tune in because Peyton was not in it, but I liked Lucas and I thought he was worth it. I've missed seeing him and Haley, but most of all, I've missed seeing him and Nathan. Even a scene with Dan would have been great. But they've completely wasted such great talent and homage to the TWO characters in which the show was meant to centre around - Lucas and Nathan as brothers. I know that all of this may seem irrelevant, but it's honestly just offensive to fans that they wasted a chance like this. Considering Chad has admitted to wanting to come back, they could have given up a 5 episode arc or something to fill in for the episodes Nathan won't be in.
February 23rd, 2012 12:49 AM
I thought the episode was really good! It didn't really pick up until more than half way through but when it did it got really intense!!
Lucas clearly hasn't been there for Haley, Brooke, or the rest of Tree Hill through a LOT of stuff over the past couple of seasons, so I didn't expect him to come back and socialize with everyone. I agree that it felt real, and his interactions with Haley have always made for one of my favourite relationships, so I enjoyed his appearance.
I usually could care less about Clay but I actually kind of like his storyline this season, especially his interactions with Logan.
I knew the cop was bad as soon as he showed up there, it just seemed like Nathan was so close and it couldn't be that simple! It seems like the dead body is going to turn up over the next couple of episodes so my guess is the storyline will be at least partially wrapped up soon enough!
Rank: Regular Character
February 23rd, 2012 12:47 AM
one word: disappointed!