8:00 PM on NBC
The-voice

The Voice Top 12 Review: Blow Michaela One Last Kiss

by at . Comments

After some seriously controversial eliminations last Thursday, The Voice returned Monday night with the Top 12 singing for their lives. Three contestants from each team performed, knowing that any two of them (regardless of team) could go home on Tuesday.

Without further ado, let's get to those performances and see who deserves to move on and who should be given the boot...

Bryan Keith Top 12

Michaela Paige - "Blow Me One Last Kiss" - Team Blake
It wasn't that the start sounded terrible, it just was way too bland. To be great you have to hold our interest even in the small moments. When she got into it, it sounded like she might get it going, but then it never seemed to go anywhere great. I loved her new hairdo, though.
Grade: C-

Dez Duron - "Can't Take My Eyes Off of You" - Team Xtina
On the other side of the coin, Dez had me curious from the first note. Whether it was his smooth tone, his ability to entertain, or just his stunning good looks, I was hooked from the jump. He can't do a million things vocally, but as long as he keeps it simple, he should be in good shape in this competition.
Grade: B+

Adriana Louise - "Good Girl" - Team Xtina
I'm usually a fan of changing up the style on a track, but it really didn't seem to work here. This song was made specifically for someone like Carrie, who has the twang to pull off some of those yelling moments. Without that twang, it felt very forced from Adriana. Then there were other times when she sounded very faint when it could have used more power. Her tone sounded very nice at least.
Grade: C+

Cody Belew - "The Best" - Team Cee Lo
I can't believe Cee Lo got rid of my boy Mackenzie Bourg so that Cody could sing this provincial track. I'm not going to speak ill of Cody tonight, because only Lord Lambert could have done something great with that song. He showed power in his vocal, but I couldn't have been more bored by during that performance. They missed the ball with that song choice.
Grade: B-

Amanda Brown - "Spectrum" - Team Adam
I am a big Amanda Brown fan, but boy was the beginning hard to listen to. It sounded like she was in between places she wanted to be with her vocal. Much of it sounded like a cat was dying somewhere in the vicinity. I hate that, because I wanted it to be great. Hopefully it was just the song choice.
Grade: B-

Bryan Keith - "Back to Black" - Team Adam
What I love about Bryan is that he is so supremely consistent. He's always going to be on key. He's always going to showcase his voice. And he's always going to bring it old school. I really enjoyed this performance. He doesn't have to try too hard, and the ease at which he sang this rendition was very fun to watch.
Grade: A-

Cassadee Pope Top 12

Cassadee Pope - "Behind These Hazel Eyes" - Team Blake
This was like the opposite of the Amanda Brown effect. I haven't been a huge Cassadee fan up to this point (well besides from her alarming good looks), but this really worked for her this week. Whether it was standing up there with the guitar or the rocker vibe to the entire track, Cassadee was on fire tonight. There was very little vibrato, which I liked, and she hit that big note that I didn't think she would.  Very good.
Grade: B+

Trevin Hunte - "When a Man Loves a Woman" - Team Cee Lo
Trevin just has a superior voice. Like Adam said, it is hard to say much after a performance like that. It's not just because it was very good, it's also because there was nothing all that special about it. It was great, no doubt, but I've seen much more special moments from contestants in the past.
Grade: A

Melanie Martinez - "Cough Syrup" - Team Adam
This was the best combination of quirkiness and seriously strong vocals that we've seen from Melanie yet. Her emotion poured through, and that put it over the top for her.
Grade: B

Nicholas David - "Power of Love" - Team Cee Lo
I can't believe Cee Lo did that to my man Saint Nick. If he had stayed with his original idea of sitting at the piano, it might have been one of those magical moments we see so rarely on these shows. Standing him up, and dressing the whole performance up in Cee Lo's style, brought it back down to earth. Oh, it was still fantastic, as is everything Nick does, highlighted by those low moments, but it could have been even better.
Grade: A-

Sylvia Yacoub - "My Heart Will Go On" - Team Xtina
I don't think it's very hard to make that song sound good. I think it's a song that is very difficult to make that song sound great. Sylvia did the first one, but not the second. It was a nice performance, but that's about it. There was absolutely nothing wrong with it, but it didn't have me sitting on the edge of my seat either.
Grade: B

Terry McDermott - "More Than a Feeling" - Team Blake
I hate to say it, because I liked Terry since the first episode of this season, but this performance made it seem like the guy is destined to be the front man of a really good cover band. He keeps doing big rock anthems, and none of them sound any different than the original. Not only that, but he also really missed the beginning of that one bit falsetto note. He's been better than this, and he will be better in the future.
Grade: B-

If I had all of America's votes I would be sending home Michaela Paige and Adriana Louise. Who do you think should go home on Tuesday night? Who do you predict WILL go home? And which was your favorite performance of the night?

Review

Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Dan Forcella is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Avatar

I love Bryan keith's voice & also the way he sing - at easy!

Avatar

I wasn't crazy about Amanda's song choice, but I'm still impressed by some of those high notes she hits and the fact that she isn't afraid to try anything. Plus, of all the contestants, she has the most "IT" factor and she looks more and more like a star every week. I can't stand that song Spectrum and she shouldn't have picked it without a cold, but I'd be disappointed if the audience didn't vote her through. The whole night was kind of a mess, and the loud band didn't help. No one "wowed" me. Nicholas and Terry were probably the best. Bryan, Casaddee, Trevin and Melanie were all OK but not amazing. Cody has a lovely voice, but that song choice was so horrible, that it's hard to judge his performance objectively. My least favorites were Dez, Adriana and Sylvia. When I think of all the good contestants who didn't make it, like Aquile, Mycle, Nicole, De'borah, Gracia, Nathalie, Avery, Mackenzie etc. (there are more, but I'm blanking on names) it really annoys me that these 3 are still around.

Terrie

I think Amanda missed the mark this week but I think she'll go on. I think Trevin oversang that song.....but he too will go on. Bryan was great. I think Terry was great. I think Nicholas David had a bad song choice....or perhaps it was the arrangement. But dude needs a make over and fast.............. What I like about The Voice is that the performances are not grossly over produced like on The X Factor. I'm kinda actually glad Christina has decided to take the spring season off. I'm tired of her constantly making it all about her. She did once again last night in mentioning she did a Celine number with Chris Mann last season. I think she'll be performing with CeeLo tonight........

Avatar

It was kind of an off night. Cee-Lo always makes bad song choices. He hosed Cody and Nicholas, who both usually sound better. I could do without anyone from Christina's team: Adriana is inconsistent, Dez is bland and Sylvia oversings everything. Bryan and Cassadee shined. Amanda tried to be too versatile and got away from her wheelhouse. Trevin and Terry played it safe but their voices are so good, it didn't matter.

Avatar

Man I miss Mackenzie... I don't know, bottom two for me would be Adriana and either Cody or Terry. I'm not a fan of Nicholas but I feel he is a good performer and one of the frontrunners right now. Still rooting for Amanda, Bryan, Cassadee, Michaela, and Trevin :)

Avatar

Amanda has been sick this entire week, sadly. But man did Bryan sound good or what!

x Close Ad