Sundays 8:00 PM on ABC

Once Upon a Time Considering Mad Hatter Recast, Spinoff

by at . Comments

Unexpected and potentially excited news tonight out of ABC and Once Upon a Time:

According to Deadline sources, the series will bring back the Mad Hatter for an episode later in Season 2.

HOWEVER, the role would be recast because the network is considering a spinoff involving the character and Sebastian Stan is unavailable for such a commitment.

Sebastian Stan on Once Upon a Time

The Mad Hatter grew into one of the show's more popular recurring players during his handful of appearances, but it's hard not to wonder if that was due to the character or Stan's portrayal of him.

Would a new actor catch on in the same fashion? Enough to build an entire series around him?

Insiders say the new actor would be brought on as a guest star with a series option in the contract, similar to deals made with Emile de Ravin and Meghan Ory.

So what do you think, Once Upon a Time fanatics? Can you imagine anyone other than Stan as the Hatter? Would you want to see such a spinoff? And which actor would you cast in it?

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.

Like Us On Facebook

Want more Once Upon a Time?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic


Once Upon a Time Pics: First Frozen Look!

The Once Upon a Time season 4 premiere will welcome Elsa and Kristoff. Get your first look at the Frozen characters here.

Tyler Jacob Moore to Freeze Over on Once Upon a Time

Tyler Jacob Moore has been cast on Once Upon a Time Season. He'll portray Hans.

Once Upon a Time Stars Preview Frozen Arc

The cast and crew of Once Upon a Time gathered at Comic-Con and talked up Once Upon a Time Season 4. Some also sang for us.

Once Upon a Time at Comic-Con: Elsa's Surprise, The Mirror's Return & More!

What did the cast of Once Upon a Time reveal today at Comic-Con? Consider yourselves spoiler warned and find out now.


Just no. It's too early for a spin off and how can they do it without the actor who portrays the character? The character is as popular as he is because of Sebastian Stan. Would they had enough material to carry on a show based soley on the Mad Hatter?


It would ruin the show. I hate when people do that if he cant do it than wait till he can or don't do it at all. it makes it look like they can't control their own tv show when people do recast.


If Stan wasn't playing the Mad Hatter not only would the spin-off be ruined but his portrayl on the show would be forever tainted and i DO NOT WANT THAT! I love his portrayl of the mad hatter and have watched each episode he has been in hundreds of times.. They can't recast it I won't allow it


I think Stan made a perfect portrail for the character, i wouldn´t like to see anybody else doing it.


The appeal was definitely because of Stan's portrayal of the character, not JUST the character. Bad idea. That's like wanting to spin-off Rumpelstiltskin but not use Robert Carlyle.


Umm,the appeal was in Sebastian Stan's amazing performance. I'd say that's a definite no on recasting and spinning off.


Dan Stevens or Ryan Seacrest?


I can't see anyone else playing the role especially walking the line between good guy and potential evil master manipulator (because I love Hook but he is more damaged goods who is consumed by rage). And seriously a spin off? Maybe they realized there is too much going on Ouat but have all this disney owned stuff but lets not stretch it too far. They just need to figure out Alice and they have enough of that world covered.


I don't know....I think that a lot of the appeal had to do with the actor and how he portrayed the character.