Reply to Post

Caitlin Idea.

1. Shane
   Guest

   I was thinking about Caitlin recently when an idea came to mind; Caitlin could be at the Carnival, she would have a power and was brought there by the Guy with Time Traveling Abilities before he died, we haven't seen her there yet (Like Doyle), and she would have a grudge against Peter. Comments?

   Posted 12/1/2009 12:14:14 AM #
2. Ravenhill
   Guest Star
   Posts: 201

   Apart from her having a power, its a good idea. But the show needs normal humans too, I think.

   Posted 12/1/2009 7:17:59 AM #
3. AHeroesChick
   Extra
   Posts: 23

   Hmmm....it would work....except that no one knows about Caitlin and where she was dropped off except for Peter!

   Posted 12/1/2009 10:22:01 AM #
4. AHeroesChick
   Extra
   Posts: 23

   And also that Caitlin was in an arc that no longer exists!

   Posted 12/1/2009 10:22:26 AM #
5. Shane
   Guest

   @Ravenhill: Thank you, I believe the same thing, but I also think that a power would be the only way to explain her being at the Carnival.

   @AHeroesChick: Caitlin would have been brought to the Carnival a few days/weeks after Peter left her, giving her feelings towards Peter enough time to develop and an opening for Arthur to have picked her up in. Oh, and because of how scared and angry she felt after being left, Lydia was able to feel her, and she was able to locate her. So. Yeah~

   Posted 12/1/2009 10:50:24 PM #
6. Ravenhill
   Guest Star
   Posts: 201

   We have no idea how time travel works, since its science fiction. When that future timeline got erased, all foreigners, like anyone not of that timeline such as Caitlin, could have been instantly snapped back to their time of origin. Caitlin could then have been found by the carnival. Lets face it, Samuel probably has a mind reader or two in his family, so they could know about her through Peter.

   Posted 12/2/2009 8:43:02 AM #
7. AHeroesChick
   Extra
   Posts: 23

   Ok, I didn't think about using Lydia...

   As far as the rules of (fictional) time travel, they'd depend upon the subjective logic of any genius or doofus out there.  I suppose Caitlin would either be stuck in a parallel universe (simultaneously existing arc) or be obliterated into nano particles as the universe reshifts the singular time space continuum.

   So, yeah....

   Posted 12/2/2009 4:46:21 PM #
8. Nick
   Guest

   im pretty sure samuel is gonna mess with Emma if he can't get Peter by using Claire as bait

   Posted 12/2/2009 10:20:04 PM #
9. Brad S
   Guest

   Are we sure Samuel is trying to get to Peter and not Noah...well, maybe more to get rid of Noah?

   It would be interesting to see if Sylar and Peter team up to take down the Carnival/Samuel.  Just a thought.

   Posted 12/3/2009 9:14:14 AM #
10. Maj
    Guest

    I was just thinking that she is the very first "Loophole" the show encountered....If the writers bring her back how many fans will return???  How many care about this character?

    Posted 12/3/2009 5:19:43 PM #

Forum is closed.