My theory o:
Okay, so Pretty Little Liars totally messes with my head and I have new theories all the time, but right now I think this one makes sense. It probably doesn't but oh well, it's just specualtion :)
Ali's murderer: Melissa
I think she found about Ali and Ian's affair and murdered her out of anger and jealousy. I then think she panicked and got Ian to help her hide the body and evidence, but they couldn't do it alone, so Ian rang up his old buddy from their club Garret. I think Jenna may have overheard the conversation while with Garret and she knows what happened that night Ali was killed, but doesn't care because she hated Ali and wanted to help protect Garret. I think Jason was involved but I only think he wandered in on what happened, either the murder or the disposing of Ali's corpse. Of course angry and hurt by his sister being murdered, he didn't inform anyone because Garret and Ian had some stuff over him, probably a bunch of secrets that would get hom in a LOT of trouble.
I always had a feeling it was Lucas and as the show progresses, I'm even more sure it's him. He's a total geek and brainiac as we all know so all the texts, and videos, and the projector in the cemetery would be easy to pull off for him. Also Ali bullied Lucas, you may say "tortured" him. In the promo for the special Halloween episode, Alison receives a voodoo doll with a note attached saying "Now, it's my turn to torture you." The actor that plays Lucas mentioned in an interview recently that he would have a part in the Halloween special, and this is the episode where certain revelations are about to be revealed. And for all the stuff A has done without being caught, leads me to believe A is quite smart, and Lucas is really smart.
Let me know what yout think of my theory and please share yours ! :)
Hiii hey you should make an account :)
The Melissa theory is very common but I'm not really sure how Jenna fits in your speculation, IMO Jenna does not have any feelings for Garret, I think she is with him for obvious reasons (to get what she wants, revenge, protection etc) and he is a cop so that makes it much easier to manipulate the girls (as we saw in the mid finale) Right now we really have no background on Garret to understand why he is part of everything and why he was in NAT
Lucas is adorkable brainy, not scary/sketchy brainy. There are times where he has been scary and the halloween ep and spoilers do point out we'll see more of it. I can believe that he did the projector I guess but that happened just an episode after he gratefully thanked Hanna for being there on his date with danielle. I can totally believe he did the Alison hate video on the fashion show, the projector maybe, and the photo's even though Jason said Ali took them (which I also can believe because Ali herself is crazy) but as for texts I'm not sure, anonymous texting sounds too out of his league.
I'm thinking either A is some rich prick who can afford having an anonymous number or just met Caleb ages before messing with the girls in Rosewood, after Aria came back. But that theory is ruled out alot because people point out that A messed with the girls before Caleb was the new kid in town. So idk, as far as texts go I think that's all just A
I like you're thinking ! xD
Melissa and Lucas have alwayd been on my radar though o.O
Even though Ali was horrible to like everyone in Rosewood :L
What do you think about Jason?
He's such a mysterious character and the fact that he doesn't remember anything from the night Ali was murdered, just seems too coincidental :/ Unless whoever killed Ali knocked him out, which has been on my mind, leading to concussion or memory loss. But he's just so shady o.O ...And sexy. But also shady xD
If Lucas is A then Ashley Benson doesn't speek the truth in an interview. Cause she says that we have seen A a lot in the last episodes of the show. But I don't know who A is, 'cause who is the one we've seen so much?
Well, Lucas has been in the background in most of the school scenes. He hasn't had big parts recently or even speaking roles, but he has still been there.
Oh and I just remembered that in the last episode the girl's were searching for Dr. Sullivan and they found that white mask and there was also a pair of shoes, so I think they found a whole costume. The costume that's been shown in the Halloween Promo, which I'm pretty sure is Lucas' costume because in an interview the actor said his costume would be the biggest surprise.
I just saw a comment on youtube that's freaked me out a bit o.O
"I Think that "A" is Maya! Think about it, Emily called Maya "pretty eyes" in the first series like the waitress did in the last ep & them boots "A" bought online were the same ones Maya wore in the last episode too (the ones Hanna commented on)."
But what on earth would Maya's motive be? :/
Somebody asked Marlene on Twitter if the boots that Maya was wearing were the same that A ordered online and she said, "No."
Well of course she'd say no :L
If she said yes, it would completely give away part of the story.
good point there jessie
When she doesn't want to answer a question she usually says "hmmm" or something similar which is why I believed her straight answer.
she might just want to throw us off guard we never know