The group goes all Justice League in this scene/episode of The Big Bang Theory. Seems about right for the show, doesn't it?
Added:

The Big Bang Theory Season 4 Episode 11 Quotes

Zack: I see, you were inferring that i'm stupid.
Sheldon: That's not correct. We were implying it... you then inferred it.

Was the starfish wearing boxer shorts? Because I'm pretty sure you were watching Nickelodeon.

Sheldon