Did Hollie deserve to be eliminated on this week's American Idol?

Like Us On Facebook

Want more ?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Searching-for-eleanor

Is Eleanor crazy?

Is Eleanor crazy?
Very-serious-mike

Who did you feel bad for?

Who did you feel bad for?

Related Post:
Created by:
Created at:
Avatar

Jessica needs to go home! Hollie should have gone home instead of Skylar but Jessica sounds like she is singing under water. JOSHUA LEDET IS THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL!

Avatar

Yes she deserves to GO HOME.... Her voice is ok... C'mon she cannot beat Jessica Sanchez!!! That's the FACT!.

Avatar

Of this group of four, Hollie was the right choice for elimination. The remaining 3 are all great talents: Phillip is the most unique, but least engaging, Jessica is the most clearly vocally gifted, but needs seasoning and maturity and Joshua is the most emotionally interesting, but has a tendency to overdo the "gospel flair" aspect of his style. So, who should win? I don't personally have a favorite among this group and I feel either one would be a reasonable choice.

Avatar

jJOSHUA is mesmerizing !! Such talent what a star can't wait for his concerts Wow he is AMAZIMG

Avatar

Hollie should still be there. Jessica should be gone. Seems the judges determined Hollie's fate with all the "Sorry Babies".

Avatar

Jessica great voice needs a few more years under her before you can give her a crown, just too young. Josh is great but sounds the same on every song, good, but redundent. Philip is the star of this show, he is so refreshing, you are looking for ward to what he is gonna do to the next song. He has this carefree attitude twards all of his music, he makes it his own. However, they will all be stars.

Avatar

Here in the U.K. we are blown away by PHillip Phillips originality and talent. America you are so lucky to have the world's next mega star. He doesn't scream & oversing his songs like Joshua & Jessica. The judges favoritism and attempts to manipulate the audience vote would never be tolerated on our screens. America what is wrong with you? Phillips is a unique and potential major talent.

Avatar

So far I have been correct in my choices. And yes I agree Holly is the right one to go next will be Phillip and the winner well anynof the two who are just super.

Avatar

Well the eliminations have gone according to my predictions so far. Next to be eliminated will be Philip, whom should have left with Elise, Skylar, and definitely Hollie. Now the final two are the BEST top singers, J & J, and my finall prediction is it will be the Cajun singer from LOUISIANA.

Avatar

yuck!!!! phillips is still there. that dude can not sing but one way. At least Joshua & Jessica should win it all. The judges are correct, Josh is the best voice I've heard in years. To bad it's a popularity contest, otherwise PP would have gone before Elise.