Sabrina finds out about the Feast of Feasts where a tribute is chosen and she becomes a queen that gets sacrificed so everyone else can eat her. Sabrina is against it, even more so when Prudence is chosen and wants to do it. She tries to convince her why this isn't a good idea, and why her faith may be misguided.

That is tested when Prudence meets her friends and finds out that Harvey is from a family of witch hunters. Prudence challenges Sabrina and her choice since he is a threat to all of them. This is proven true when his family goes hunting and they all witness how a familiar is killed by the Kinkle family.

Sabrina still tries to figure out a way to get the feast canceled, all while Prudence enjoys her week as queen. She has an orgy with Ambrose, Luke, Nick, and her sisters. 

When Lady Blackwood reveals that she cast a spell on Prudence, Sabrina realizes that she did it on purpose so that her husband's illegitimate child doesn't try to take the throne from her twins. This is confirmed with Hilda's truth cake and Sabrina tells Father Blackwood to stop this annual feast. 

He tries but someone else sacrifices herself and everyone feasts on her. 

In the end, Dorcas and Agatha hide from Prudence that they plan to get revenge for the witches by killing Harvey and his brother.