PART I: Natalie and Cris enjoy a bit of trick-or-treating to lift their spirits following a disastrous evening at the Palace. Assuring Jared she has no ulterior motives, Sarah invites her date to come in for a cup of hot cocoa. The person in the Grim Reaper costume secretly watches Starr (Kristen Alderson) and her friends as they watch a scary movie together. Astonished to recognize his sister-in-law as one of the drag queens performing on stage, John realizes he has to create a distraction to keep Ramsey in the dark.
PART II: Natalie can't shake thoughts of Jared as she sits chatting with Cristian (David Fumero) in Angel Square. Meanwhile, Jared is jarred by seductive visions of Natalie while he says goodnight to Sarah. Marty suggests to a scornful Blair that they team up to prevent bloodshed between John and Todd. Starr screams to catch a glimpse of the Grim Reaper through the window at La Boulet. Ramsey taunts John about Caitlin's untimely demise. John throws the first punch in what quickly becomes a full blown brawl.
Cole, Markko and Langston find Starr's story difficult to swallow.
EPILOGUE: After the police clear the entire club, Marcie (Kathy Brier) thanks Clarence and Brandon before making her escape with "Aaron" in tow. Blair decides Marty might be right after all when Todd calls asking for bail money. Blair (Kassie DePaiva) and Marty agree to catch a flight to Atlanta first thing in the morning.